From 09f06229c7c1143b1a348d4e3d165344dcb0b905 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Adrian Kummerlaender Date: Thu, 31 Jan 2019 14:18:05 +0100 Subject: Add cylinder2d outflow refinement plot --- content.tex | 18 +- ...der2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.gnuplot | 13 + ...w_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen.gnuplot | 14 + ...inder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_0.csv | 452 ++++ ...inder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_1.csv | 2243 ++++++++++++++++++++ ...ylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.pdf | Bin 0 -> 92972 bytes ...d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen.pdf | Bin 0 -> 60467 bytes ...ylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s.pdf | Bin 0 -> 154487 bytes ...d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s_knudsen.pdf | Bin 0 -> 75365 bytes ...2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_n5_knudsen.pdf | Bin 0 -> 65754 bytes ...ylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.png | Bin 0 -> 32873 bytes ...d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen.png | Bin 0 -> 16849 bytes ...ylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s.png | Bin 0 -> 75561 bytes ...d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s_knudsen.png | Bin 0 -> 30390 bytes ...2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_n5_knudsen.png | Bin 0 -> 33675 bytes 15 files changed, 2734 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) create mode 100644 img/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.gnuplot create mode 100644 img/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen.gnuplot create mode 100644 img/data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_0.csv create mode 100644 img/data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_1.csv create mode 100644 img/static/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.pdf create mode 100644 img/static/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen.pdf create mode 100644 img/static/cylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s.pdf create mode 100644 img/static/cylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s_knudsen.pdf create mode 100644 img/static/cylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_n5_knudsen.pdf create mode 100644 img/tmp/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.png create mode 100644 img/tmp/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen.png create mode 100644 img/tmp/cylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s.png create mode 100644 img/tmp/cylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s_knudsen.png create mode 100644 img/tmp/cylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_n5_knudsen.png diff --git a/content.tex b/content.tex index bf7c9a3..4f298a0 100644 --- a/content.tex +++ b/content.tex @@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ So trifft es sich, dass der Wunsch nach theoretischer Lösung komplexer und nur Während Finite Elemente Methoden den wohl verbreitetsten Ansatz zur numerischen Strömungsdynamik bilden, erfreut sich auch die Herangehensweise der Lattice Boltzmann Methoden in den letzten Jahrzehnten wachsender Nutzbarkeit und Verbreitung. Im Gegensatz zu anderen Lösungsmethoden werden hier die strömungsbeschreibenden Navier-Stokes Gleichungen nicht direkt numerisch gelöst. Lösungen ergeben sich vielmehr aus der Simulation des Fluidverhaltens auf \emph{mesoskopischer} Ebene -- d.h. aus der Betrachtung nicht aus Sicht der Kollision einzelner Fluidpartikel und nicht aus Sicht der analytischen Strömungsbeschreibung, sondern aus Sicht der Wahrscheinlichkeit, dass sich das Fluid zu bestimmter Zeit an einem bestimmten Ort mit bestimmter Geschwindigkeit bewegt. \bigskip -Ein Vorteil dieses, auf den Arbeiten von Ludwig Eduard Boltzmann im Bereich der statistischen Physik aufbauenden, Ansatzes ist seine Eignung für komplexe Geometrien mit verschiedensten Randbedingungen. Weiterhin gewinnt in den letzten Jahren auch die sehr gute Parallelisierbarkeit von Lattice Boltzmann Methoden in Hinblick auf einen technischen Fortschritt an Anziehungskraft, nach welchem die Leistungsfähigkeit von Großrechnern eher aus deren Parallelität als aus individueller Prozessorleistung erwächst. +Ein Vorteil dieses, auf den Arbeiten von Ludwig Eduard Boltzmann im Bereich der statistischen Physik aufbauenden, Ansatzes, ist seine Eignung für komplexe Geometrien mit verschiedensten Randbedingungen. Weiterhin gewinnt in den letzten Jahren auch die sehr gute Parallelisierbarkeit von Lattice Boltzmann Methoden in Hinblick auf einen technischen Fortschritt an Anziehungskraft, nach welchem die Leistungsfähigkeit von Großrechnern eher aus deren Parallelität als aus individueller Prozessorleistung erwächst. \subsection{Warum Gitterverfeinerung?} @@ -1013,16 +1013,22 @@ Insgesamt war unter dieser formaleren Analyse unsere intuitive Wahl des in Abbil \caption{Verbesserte Verfeinerungsstruktur um den Zylinder} \end{figure} +Typischerweise sind LBM-Simulationen des umströmten Zylinders für wirbelbildende Reynolds-Zahlen bei kleineren Auflösungen empfindlich gegenüber Divergenz im Ausflussbereich. So divergiert ein uniform mit \(N=5\) aufgelöstes Gitter mit den verwendeten Parametern und Randbedingungen schon nach wenigen Schritten. Es wäre vorteilhaft, wenn sich dieses Problem unter Einsatz möglichst weniger zusätzlicher Gitterknoten beheben ließe -- etwa durch Verfeinerung des Ausflussbereiches. Und tatsächlich genügt schon die Verfeinerung eines schmalen Stücks des Ausgangsbereiches zur Stabilisierung der Simulation bei dieser niedrigen Auflösung. In Abbildung~\ref{fig:CylinderOptimizedGridN5} sehen wir den Geschwindigkeitsplot eines solchen Gitters. + \begin{figure}[h] \begin{adjustbox}{center} -\includegraphics[width=1.2\textwidth]{img/static/cylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s.pdf} -\end{adjustbox} -\begin{adjustbox}{center} -\includegraphics[width=1.2\textwidth]{img/static/cylinder2d_optimized_low_resolution_grid_60s_knudsen.pdf} +\includegraphics[width=1.2\textwidth]{img/static/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.pdf} \end{adjustbox} -\caption{Analyse eines informiert verfeinerten Gitters mit \(N=5\) zu \(t=60s\)} +\caption{Stabile Zylinderumströmung mit \(N=5\) durch Ausgangsverfeinerung} +\label{fig:CylinderOptimizedGridN5} \end{figure} +Dieses Beispiel gewinnt insbesondere an Eindruck, wenn wir die Gesamtanzahl der Gitterzellen mit den für ein stabiles uniformes Gitter benötigten Zellen vergleichen: Während das im Ausgang verfeinerte Gitter nur 2693 aktive Zellen beinhaltet, benötigt ein stabiles uniformes Gitter eine Auflösung von \(N=9\), was 7326 Zellen entspricht. Interessieren wir uns an dieser Stelle also nur für ein subjektiv korrektes und nicht-divergentes Strömungsbild, so ermöglicht uns Gitterverfeinerung ein Auskommen mit nur knapp einem Drittel der für ein unverfeinertes Gitter benötigten Zellen. + +\bigskip + +Auf diese Weise illustriert sich hier auch ein bisher nur in der Einführung erwähnter Vorteil von Gitterverfeinerung: Selbst wenn ein Verfeinerungsverfahren bezogen auf den Fehler im Vergleich mit analytischen Lösungen keine Verbesserungen oder sogar leichte Einbußen produziert, kann es doch potenziell eingesetzt werden, um Probleme zu behandeln, welche anderweitig nicht oder nur mit deutlich höherem Speicher- und Rechenaufwand zugänglich wären. + \subsubsection{Vergleich von Widerstands- und Auftriebskräften} \newpage diff --git a/img/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.gnuplot b/img/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.gnuplot new file mode 100644 index 0000000..42ec009 --- /dev/null +++ b/img/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s.gnuplot @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +plotname = "cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s" + +load 'common/velocity_fluid.gnuplot' + +plot 'data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_1.csv' using ($6+0.05):($7+0.05):(sqrt($2*$2+$3*$3)) palette pt 5 ps 5.3 notitle,\ + 'data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_0.csv' using 6:($7+0.05):(sqrt($2*$2+$3*$3)) palette pt 5 ps 2.6 notitle\ + +load 'common/velocity_wrapper.gnuplot' + +set obj 3 rect from 20.95,0 to 22,4.1 +set obj 3 fillstyle empty border -1 front lw 1 + +load 'common/include_fluid.gnuplot' diff --git a/img/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen.gnuplot b/img/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen.gnuplot new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ca0d5e9 --- /dev/null +++ b/img/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen.gnuplot @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +plotname = "cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_knudsen" +knudsen = 0.000866025 + +load 'common/knudsen_fluid.gnuplot' + +plot 'data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_1.csv' using ($6+0.05):($7+0.05):(log($5/knudsen)/log(2)) palette pt 5 ps 5.3 notitle,\ + 'data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_0.csv' using 6:($7+0.05):(log($5/knudsen)/log(2)) palette pt 5 ps 2.6 notitle\ + +load 'common/knudsen_wrapper.gnuplot' + +set obj 3 rect from 20.95,0 to 22,4.1 +set obj 3 fillstyle empty border -1 front lw 1 + +load 'common/include_fluid.gnuplot' diff --git a/img/data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_0.csv b/img/data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_0.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4bd6bf5 --- /dev/null +++ b/img/data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_0.csv @@ -0,0 +1,452 @@ +geometry,ux,uy,p,knudsen,x,y +2,0.0711663887,-0.0152818523,0.0674520284,0.00472667115,21,0 +2,0,0,0.288896948,0.00907182414,21.1000004,0 +1,0.15914993,-0.0110848732,0.152851343,0.00436184602,21,0.100000001 +1,0.153788701,0.0214747414,0.189800173,0.0075801122,21.1000004,0.100000001 +2,0,0,0.0975460857,0.00714418525,21.2000008,0 +1,0.135523722,0.00688041747,0.0838564411,0.00564499991,21.2000008,0.100000001 +2,0,0,0.119685493,0.00332184578,21.2999992,0 +1,0.133850262,-0.00450307317,0.130859658,0.00329627399,21.2999992,0.100000001 +2,0,0,0.157512859,0.00826124754,21.3999996,0 +1,0.149485692,-0.0034876545,0.162787899,0.00905244052,21.3999996,0.100000001 +2,0,0,0.141626418,0.000652683491,21.5,0 +1,0.159085274,-0.0177835543,0.138534069,0.00160362071,21.5,0.100000001 +2,0,0,0.0789687559,0.0130744278,21.6000004,0 +1,0.166165143,0.0148803294,0.101391986,0.011477774,21.6000004,0.100000001 +2,0,0,0.191134214,0.00280878227,21.7000008,0 +1,0.179716393,-0.0371810719,0.113241211,0.00365742645,21.7000008,0.100000001 +2,0,0,0.0618002899,0.015290847,21.7999992,0 +1,0.221411437,0.0295424815,0.145788103,0.017762769,21.7999992,0.100000001 +2,0,0,0.101977095,0.00592208374,21.8999996,0 +1,0.144272402,-0.0338591225,0.0980393216,0.0121722389,21.8999996,0.100000001 +2,0,0,0.0576846786,0.0227414332,22,0 +4,0.439429194,0,0,0.0683519095,22,0.100000001 +1,0.249018803,-0.00759227807,0.213767305,0.00599785894,21,0.200000003 +1,0.246119961,-0.0008172901,0.0874106213,0.00370546384,21.1000004,0.200000003 +1,0.255782396,0.0333084352,0.173217461,0.00432034954,21.2000008,0.200000003 +1,0.271556109,-0.0268893726,0.165117308,0.00263766921,21.2999992,0.200000003 +1,0.265310705,0.00161199877,0.099771224,0.00626629358,21.3999996,0.200000003 +1,0.280594558,-0.0351038389,0.127162188,0.00128674693,21.5,0.200000003 +1,0.302455634,-0.0152924908,0.162922919,0.0084143253,21.6000004,0.200000003 +1,0.359026551,-0.0502744056,0.0818019286,0.00463377358,21.7000008,0.200000003 +1,0.340289325,0.00575665804,0.107306398,0.0122581655,21.7999992,0.200000003 +1,0.473855436,-0.0800756961,0.103550769,0.00929924194,21.8999996,0.200000003 +4,0.432973146,0,0,0.0521535724,22,0.200000003 +1,0.343391001,-0.00390937086,0.247643545,0.00530541968,21,0.300000012 +1,0.345113873,0.00714712916,0.132522702,0.00409946125,21.1000004,0.300000012 +1,0.351836532,0.0188916754,0.177703887,0.00452628452,21.2000008,0.300000012 +1,0.362971574,-0.0425327532,0.136608183,0.00421159063,21.2999992,0.300000012 +1,0.373912454,-0.00826687552,0.123490341,0.00551893888,21.3999996,0.300000012 +1,0.403547585,-0.0553680025,0.128789112,0.00355221843,21.5,0.300000012 +1,0.417575955,-0.0422378443,0.15310666,0.0071626734,21.6000004,0.300000012 +1,0.429239213,-0.084038198,0.117264047,0.00887191109,21.7000008,0.300000012 +1,0.50710094,-0.0203921162,0.0827295706,0.0148935905,21.7999992,0.300000012 +1,0.500897527,-0.290266573,0.0930892155,0.0308631007,21.8999996,0.300000012 +4,0.803999603,0,0,0.12977995,22,0.300000012 +1,0.434412539,-0.00272023957,0.262149155,0.00395876681,21,0.400000006 +1,0.448685229,0.0147867855,0.200674698,0.00451724185,21.1000004,0.400000006 +1,0.460020125,-0.013888672,0.116844229,0.00307087367,21.2000008,0.400000006 +1,0.473800749,-0.0324037559,0.1237275,0.00319863949,21.2999992,0.400000006 +1,0.475063235,-0.0373860598,0.198898822,0.00190851558,21.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.504335225,-0.0571142174,0.128723636,0.00504718209,21.5,0.400000006 +1,0.492174268,-0.080227308,0.0977531895,0.00412734691,21.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.546309471,-0.0921195671,0.147602856,0.00511991326,21.7000008,0.400000006 +1,0.541978598,-0.101241715,0.123548746,0.00708227884,21.7999992,0.400000006 +1,0.645923376,-0.227570146,0.0893385112,0.0162246134,21.8999996,0.400000006 +4,0.414701283,0,0,0.0583098009,22,0.400000006 +1,0.513138771,-0.00835868251,0.263193011,0.00265770359,21,0.5 +1,0.534157813,-0.00604252843,0.180780798,0.00400227075,21.1000004,0.5 +1,0.546805084,-0.0256178193,0.160845444,0.000403179962,21.2000008,0.5 +1,0.547154188,-0.0237241983,0.155824184,0.00318110548,21.2999992,0.5 +1,0.548409879,-0.0606254376,0.157596231,0.00293872552,21.3999996,0.5 +1,0.563487172,-0.0723933727,0.141301855,0.00468292087,21.5,0.5 +1,0.588392317,-0.0755744651,0.145657793,0.00430413475,21.6000004,0.5 +1,0.593037724,-0.175346971,0.137969851,0.00744849117,21.7000008,0.5 +1,0.686762989,-0.0580446124,0.113050036,0.0179696679,21.7999992,0.5 +1,0.609165549,-0.389470071,0.131950513,0.039314732,21.8999996,0.5 +4,1.00037324,0,0,0.180134863,22,0.5 +1,0.58545959,-0.0149808684,0.253499389,0.00167156372,21,0.600000024 +1,0.593074262,-0.0178330801,0.142448127,0.00261395331,21.1000004,0.600000024 +1,0.590401649,-0.0228077956,0.198452279,0.00100667775,21.2000008,0.600000024 +1,0.60550791,-0.0282781981,0.182456449,0.00528038619,21.2999992,0.600000024 +1,0.610630989,-0.0792059451,0.126810074,0.00310744205,21.3999996,0.600000024 +1,0.630138218,-0.0730743855,0.164062023,0.00477793813,21.5,0.600000024 +1,0.63008076,-0.109573774,0.191794127,0.00262353313,21.6000004,0.600000024 +1,0.668885827,-0.164152071,0.140479907,0.00313510164,21.7000008,0.600000024 +1,0.608929276,-0.128301978,0.111358099,0.0120830974,21.7999992,0.600000024 +1,0.753516138,-0.331762493,0.168379277,0.0262749922,21.8999996,0.600000024 +4,0.367362738,0,0,0.0690863952,22,0.600000024 +1,0.655291855,-0.0166363381,0.234404311,0.00174205296,21,0.699999988 +1,0.652359366,-0.0106540537,0.17328231,0.00373412156,21.1000004,0.699999988 +1,0.649540007,-0.0306156464,0.17122902,0.00132841396,21.2000008,0.699999988 +1,0.662210703,-0.0550793111,0.181399733,0.00465089921,21.2999992,0.699999988 +1,0.678525448,-0.0731109977,0.188284352,0.000782637799,21.3999996,0.699999988 +1,0.677269995,-0.102443472,0.176678389,0.00396933313,21.5,0.699999988 +1,0.708693743,-0.113166958,0.159226343,0.00264668185,21.6000004,0.699999988 +1,0.699812353,-0.199821442,0.175450012,0.00672231428,21.7000008,0.699999988 +1,0.806939542,-0.0884884074,0.178324699,0.0233277269,21.7999992,0.699999988 +1,0.655706465,-0.426204354,0.167426825,0.0392508134,21.8999996,0.699999988 +4,1.16160953,0,0,0.224793136,22,0.699999988 +1,0.719609797,-0.0179787744,0.215981454,0.00185659144,21,0.800000012 +1,0.723109722,2.16691387E-05,0.215542629,0.00433003018,21.1000004,0.800000012 +1,0.725837648,-0.0436023213,0.184190303,0.000930018665,21.2000008,0.800000012 +1,0.735358059,-0.0571871772,0.182539344,0.00412303023,21.2999992,0.800000012 +1,0.735423148,-0.0802908838,0.212673947,0.00176184415,21.3999996,0.800000012 +1,0.745315731,-0.104088984,0.20174326,0.00509981252,21.5,0.800000012 +1,0.735075831,-0.131440476,0.164164484,0.00572766783,21.6000004,0.800000012 +1,0.762347698,-0.193443015,0.214071751,0.00875230692,21.7000008,0.800000012 +1,0.670109332,-0.145645842,0.208834946,0.0193991605,21.7999992,0.800000012 +1,0.845121324,-0.335682482,0.179398298,0.0355303064,21.8999996,0.800000012 +4,0.327739775,0,0,0.0807142258,22,0.800000012 +1,0.778775454,-0.0220971685,0.210971564,0.00131630478,21,0.899999976 +1,0.787389696,-0.0137686515,0.223307341,0.00366090867,21.1000004,0.899999976 +1,0.7974509,-0.0483314395,0.235839546,0.00126483035,21.2000008,0.899999976 +1,0.793939471,-0.0595097505,0.206413761,0.00348172057,21.2999992,0.899999976 +1,0.799029171,-0.0846866891,0.190805465,0.000969251618,21.3999996,0.899999976 +1,0.793328166,-0.122757331,0.224283084,0.000935384422,21.5,0.899999976 +1,0.826961219,-0.106406063,0.223846972,0.00559467357,21.6000004,0.899999976 +1,0.763019562,-0.209691972,0.218913078,0.00691497,21.7000008,0.899999976 +1,0.88609463,-0.129928008,0.2187673,0.0195200201,21.7999992,0.899999976 +1,0.721653879,-0.402634591,0.201260313,0.0324985199,21.8999996,0.899999976 +4,1.27845716,0,0,0.262518913,22,0.899999976 +1,0.826542079,-0.0277351532,0.212709427,0.000749307335,21,1 +1,0.831771493,-0.0225255713,0.230595723,0.00265932688,21.1000004,1 +1,0.836048603,-0.0455482565,0.228502184,0.00253515807,21.2000008,1 +1,0.835797012,-0.0561199002,0.239962995,0.00364207872,21.2999992,1 +1,0.832901597,-0.0851053074,0.222474605,0.00281740911,21.3999996,1 +1,0.832674325,-0.11440675,0.227547348,0.00369189098,21.5,1 +1,0.80153352,-0.105349928,0.239683151,0.00761647709,21.6000004,1 +1,0.837178409,-0.186062396,0.264442861,0.0154878953,21.7000008,1 +1,0.684777915,-0.133537963,0.222746059,0.0310917087,21.7999992,1 +1,0.863452435,-0.317021668,0.320646614,0.045276992,21.8999996,1 +4,0.0922865421,0,0,0.0925148576,22,1 +1,0.85452497,-0.0353571624,0.219082341,0.000470926869,21,1.10000002 +1,0.855829835,-0.0306981243,0.254001111,0.0017482515,21.1000004,1.10000002 +1,0.861216187,-0.0439291075,0.221594706,0.0015294241,21.2000008,1.10000002 +1,0.853300571,-0.0663471073,0.253251344,0.00170468399,21.2999992,1.10000002 +1,0.863347292,-0.0742326304,0.260728002,0.00216731429,21.3999996,1.10000002 +1,0.839706123,-0.108282879,0.235236004,0.00147790113,21.5,1.10000002 +1,0.864349723,-0.0987143666,0.244366437,0.00421945984,21.6000004,1.10000002 +1,0.796957016,-0.170272022,0.27520892,0.00871430058,21.7000008,1.10000002 +1,0.927431762,-0.0767548457,0.289541274,0.0291020777,21.7999992,1.10000002 +1,0.594982624,-0.25028792,0.290733457,0.0414721444,21.8999996,1.10000002 +4,1.32786107,0,0,0.288275868,22,1.10000002 +1,0.869499505,-0.0428897813,0.229173481,0.000318466715,21,1.20000005 +1,0.870908678,-0.029200105,0.265620798,0.00169691665,21.1000004,1.20000005 +1,0.870588303,-0.041243393,0.265269488,0.00170183717,21.2000008,1.20000005 +1,0.868100822,-0.0643451586,0.255216092,0.00216717576,21.2999992,1.20000005 +1,0.860101759,-0.0641389489,0.243992716,0.00395921012,21.3999996,1.20000005 +1,0.859547198,-0.105723977,0.281599075,0.00778391585,21.5,1.20000005 +1,0.815366924,-0.0836940035,0.264780253,0.0108667035,21.6000004,1.20000005 +1,0.860087037,-0.161821812,0.269102544,0.0165733155,21.7000008,1.20000005 +1,0.681248963,-0.0721068382,0.293506533,0.0286278427,21.7999992,1.20000005 +1,0.906580806,-0.131032735,0.293337017,0.0432337709,21.8999996,1.20000005 +4,0.347913295,0,0,0.0793288574,22,1.20000005 +1,0.87500447,-0.0494427942,0.240740955,0.000492270687,21,1.29999995 +1,0.876418471,-0.0335554145,0.268714279,0.00169704214,21.1000004,1.29999995 +1,0.878902435,-0.0397478826,0.288720518,0.0017578128,21.2000008,1.29999995 +1,0.869648218,-0.0602607839,0.263633788,0.00110325392,21.2999992,1.29999995 +1,0.875296891,-0.0562053733,0.246953681,0.00161661801,21.3999996,1.29999995 +1,0.838909745,-0.090174526,0.292553127,0.0032145658,21.5,1.29999995 +1,0.879155099,-0.0798387751,0.292617321,0.00734258583,21.6000004,1.29999995 +1,0.804775774,-0.126503929,0.245411053,0.00804652367,21.7000008,1.29999995 +1,0.940874577,-0.0875919238,0.304335445,0.0289725736,21.7999992,1.29999995 +1,0.815825045,-0.218076363,0.223752856,0.0391236171,21.8999996,1.29999995 +4,1.38286531,0,0,0.290618896,22,1.29999995 +1,0.872364759,-0.0519310348,0.255647182,0.000668309629,21,1.39999998 +1,0.872466564,-0.0352304317,0.282363445,0.00153772859,21.1000004,1.39999998 +1,0.869651616,-0.0356452316,0.258622825,0.00224937964,21.2000008,1.39999998 +1,0.865856946,-0.0532014146,0.279103518,0.00366445491,21.2999992,1.39999998 +1,0.842951775,-0.0412091352,0.290200114,0.0045133424,21.3999996,1.39999998 +1,0.85317266,-0.0831451863,0.271528602,0.00719495397,21.5,1.39999998 +1,0.79115212,-0.0594486743,0.278555453,0.00920185633,21.6000004,1.39999998 +1,0.838657677,-0.107368045,0.329325259,0.0146680055,21.7000008,1.39999998 +1,0.657577991,-0.0786205456,0.277871132,0.0327237584,21.7999992,1.39999998 +1,0.8689816,-0.236851782,0.319614321,0.0430855788,21.8999996,1.39999998 +4,0.157520697,0,0,0.0869519338,22,1.39999998 +1,0.863167286,-0.0467606001,0.27665621,0.000741039636,21,1.5 +1,0.855551422,-0.0342740938,0.28395623,0.00143882108,21.1000004,1.5 +1,0.858634531,-0.0276715215,0.258709788,0.00208172551,21.2000008,1.5 +1,0.832909226,-0.0357393213,0.278513342,0.00268956623,21.2999992,1.5 +1,0.830870092,-0.0365979709,0.303391248,0.0025391269,21.3999996,1.5 +1,0.803121865,-0.058938086,0.2621378,0.00377494143,21.5,1.5 +1,0.826616645,-0.0479340702,0.295078456,0.00703246798,21.6000004,1.5 +1,0.737915814,-0.0853556916,0.32129097,0.011986779,21.7000008,1.5 +1,0.897498965,-0.054172717,0.305229187,0.030973522,21.7999992,1.5 +1,0.524999082,-0.1240834,0.315857619,0.0430143401,21.8999996,1.5 +4,1.30204785,0,0,0.280983448,22,1.5 +1,0.850164294,-0.0345674865,0.298821211,0.00127851916,21,1.60000002 +1,0.836224854,-0.0312464535,0.264241189,0.00241676951,21.1000004,1.60000002 +1,0.814352095,-0.0124278972,0.280154377,0.00301544648,21.2000008,1.60000002 +1,0.811256111,-0.0255669374,0.275213182,0.0039854194,21.2999992,1.60000002 +1,0.785134017,-0.0232286528,0.272427708,0.00391770247,21.3999996,1.60000002 +1,0.79273814,-0.0499924831,0.304545313,0.00562632224,21.5,1.60000002 +1,0.730738878,-0.0272811558,0.307903379,0.00967574771,21.6000004,1.60000002 +1,0.803168356,-0.0930236429,0.293219656,0.0145747615,21.7000008,1.60000002 +1,0.608510196,-0.0261120442,0.292046458,0.0285016093,21.7999992,1.60000002 +1,0.849344254,-0.0316478275,0.351160765,0.040328227,21.8999996,1.60000002 +4,0.257752359,0,0,0.0752893761,22,1.60000002 +1,0.835353613,-0.0120648891,0.318805665,0.00142669969,21,1.70000005 +1,0.811671317,-0.00307981763,0.243091807,0.0025998929,21.1000004,1.70000005 +1,0.794403732,0.00100003474,0.281697571,0.00204050587,21.2000008,1.70000005 +1,0.776438713,-0.013129876,0.276784092,0.00142177811,21.2999992,1.70000005 +1,0.78293407,-0.0119587146,0.274996251,0.00218183431,21.3999996,1.70000005 +1,0.746649563,-0.0285166055,0.306451231,0.00275759934,21.5,1.70000005 +1,0.788363755,-0.0348884463,0.313980818,0.00805636588,21.6000004,1.70000005 +1,0.716472149,-0.0654422939,0.269058555,0.0105104381,21.7000008,1.70000005 +1,0.868337929,-0.0113489404,0.318801492,0.0296650268,21.7999992,1.70000005 +1,0.713251054,-0.140965745,0.257130504,0.0411496684,21.8999996,1.70000005 +4,1.32761002,0,0,0.278476834,22,1.70000005 +1,0.822585523,0.0125726592,0.334542692,0.0014498448,21,1.79999995 +1,0.806760132,0.0224667583,0.250105888,0.00281821121,21.1000004,1.79999995 +1,0.778700411,0.0123036047,0.261456281,0.00201296969,21.2000008,1.79999995 +1,0.780733824,-0.0048887399,0.286664337,0.00265243487,21.2999992,1.79999995 +1,0.74978292,0.0021685434,0.300247073,0.00440502353,21.3999996,1.79999995 +1,0.767520547,-0.0282259639,0.288400263,0.00589235267,21.5,1.79999995 +1,0.713340521,-0.0226567853,0.287334889,0.00811618939,21.6000004,1.79999995 +1,0.774038017,-0.050452482,0.334782302,0.00982626341,21.7000008,1.79999995 +1,0.607908189,-0.047902301,0.303546488,0.0262271538,21.7999992,1.79999995 +1,0.842114866,-0.128997475,0.302786261,0.0392396115,21.8999996,1.79999995 +4,0.183317989,0,0,0.0873397216,22,1.79999995 +1,0.816947699,0.0309976544,0.342282504,0.00115191378,21,1.89999998 +1,0.804222405,0.040438313,0.271456331,0.00253363629,21.1000004,1.89999998 +1,0.803073049,0.0214904938,0.27732411,0.00191344274,21.2000008,1.89999998 +1,0.777929366,0.0167875383,0.2713269,0.00211409945,21.2999992,1.89999998 +1,0.775052249,0.0049301316,0.303241611,0.00231271866,21.3999996,1.89999998 +1,0.754927814,-0.0182778277,0.29207775,0.00320924306,21.5,1.89999998 +1,0.785670519,-0.00755046681,0.306799293,0.00818737317,21.6000004,1.89999998 +1,0.711095691,-0.0524526983,0.313851923,0.0111587774,21.7000008,1.89999998 +1,0.867004991,-0.0430101082,0.321092099,0.0294303857,21.7999992,1.89999998 +1,0.621235192,-0.112296835,0.282110065,0.0421354733,21.8999996,1.89999998 +4,1.31926858,0,0,0.282206386,22,1.89999998 +1,0.816725194,0.0470157973,0.343737185,0.000987532199,21,2 +1,0.814535499,0.0491061695,0.280232251,0.00274440972,21.1000004,2 +1,0.795323551,0.0348210819,0.278334618,0.00389867043,21.2000008,2 +1,0.795510173,0.032664746,0.278529048,0.00513336901,21.2999992,2 +1,0.766617656,0.0119554847,0.291199595,0.00398735376,21.3999996,2 +1,0.778231978,-0.00533280661,0.307461739,0.00287374412,21.5,2 +1,0.717032433,-0.00550646428,0.325024575,0.00857613236,21.6000004,2 +1,0.7922737,-0.0408553965,0.308236808,0.0126664797,21.7000008,2 +1,0.614841938,-0.0303896833,0.282802373,0.029915832,21.7999992,2 +1,0.849881768,-0.102115147,0.390567273,0.0451560616,21.8999996,2 +4,0.166252613,0,0,0.0932453051,22,2 +1,0.821459174,0.0616664924,0.339572251,0.001027363,21,2.0999999 +1,0.811920762,0.0546618737,0.261550397,0.0021429297,21.1000004,2.0999999 +1,0.808574021,0.048930455,0.271276504,0.00229144981,21.2000008,2.0999999 +1,0.785261273,0.0375412703,0.298872143,0.00201505586,21.2999992,2.0999999 +1,0.796059549,0.0195757411,0.301277041,0.00249468256,21.3999996,2.0999999 +1,0.771791697,0.0132103767,0.286771297,0.00309020025,21.5,2.0999999 +1,0.798457742,-0.0124535039,0.334013611,0.00696948636,21.6000004,2.0999999 +1,0.737329185,-0.0386906639,0.315547794,0.0113177449,21.7000008,2.0999999 +1,0.891563714,0.0105900206,0.320489824,0.0332733355,21.7999992,2.0999999 +1,0.596233308,-0.129730687,0.328417957,0.0477941632,21.8999996,2.0999999 +4,1.327281,0,0,0.287670135,22,2.0999999 +1,0.832468808,0.0749011114,0.329177916,0.00121228513,21,2.20000005 +1,0.822443306,0.0746682286,0.257519722,0.00292748353,21.1000004,2.20000005 +1,0.799992085,0.0600145496,0.273078859,0.00248876936,21.2000008,2.20000005 +1,0.808426499,0.0485471301,0.305327266,0.00345365424,21.2999992,2.20000005 +1,0.785068989,0.0204829872,0.305594116,0.00601066742,21.3999996,2.20000005 +1,0.80436331,0.0266456548,0.306605995,0.00865350012,21.5,2.20000005 +1,0.748025656,-0.0050123292,0.307622135,0.0104928128,21.6000004,2.20000005 +1,0.810103774,-0.0398027897,0.347164005,0.0111025143,21.7000008,2.20000005 +1,0.632488966,0.00556261186,0.328992605,0.0294378623,21.7999992,2.20000005 +1,0.874614894,-0.0225810315,0.321995616,0.0418052971,21.8999996,2.20000005 +4,0.2018006,0,0,0.0981336609,22,2.20000005 +1,0.852924943,0.0891957283,0.310423583,0.00108254422,21,2.29999995 +1,0.837569773,0.085465081,0.276038766,0.00321450969,21.1000004,2.29999995 +1,0.837085783,0.0586443432,0.31021288,0.0019706923,21.2000008,2.29999995 +1,0.827453554,0.0484907962,0.277984381,0.00224724435,21.2999992,2.29999995 +1,0.839532673,0.0317193195,0.296422213,0.00194771402,21.3999996,2.29999995 +1,0.805732787,0.0167416912,0.345360488,0.00326757762,21.5,2.29999995 +1,0.864690006,0.0102800326,0.32183376,0.00980840623,21.6000004,2.29999995 +1,0.780574262,-0.0109978644,0.289919049,0.010106815,21.7000008,2.29999995 +1,0.931343496,-0.0495538786,0.379639894,0.0300417673,21.7999992,2.29999995 +1,0.815231323,-0.0682517588,0.247075751,0.0431975201,21.8999996,2.29999995 +4,1.41940105,0,0,0.30253613,22,2.29999995 +1,0.876814067,0.0980156437,0.288537204,0.0011305298,21,2.4000001 +1,0.878033221,0.100616589,0.30551064,0.00337570743,21.1000004,2.4000001 +1,0.873768508,0.0581870712,0.306385547,0.00400499534,21.2000008,2.4000001 +1,0.882547498,0.0589360893,0.296115011,0.00578519329,21.2999992,2.4000001 +1,0.859889269,0.0379611924,0.302682817,0.00522230892,21.3999996,2.4000001 +1,0.873022854,0.0306038521,0.334050566,0.00697102025,21.5,2.4000001 +1,0.808285296,0.00433609495,0.332829744,0.0138029661,21.6000004,2.4000001 +1,0.877822101,0.0290530492,0.351331025,0.0218461547,21.7000008,2.4000001 +1,0.655748904,-0.0273963362,0.335731804,0.0382780991,21.7999992,2.4000001 +1,0.902608871,-0.184603766,0.399461716,0.0447431728,21.8999996,2.4000001 +4,0.204682782,0,0,0.0949264616,22,2.4000001 +1,0.900437832,0.0937146321,0.267075956,0.00134989945,21,2.5 +1,0.908195913,0.0810247585,0.318670124,0.0021372519,21.1000004,2.5 +1,0.930083752,0.0598016791,0.28097108,0.00262336852,21.2000008,2.5 +1,0.910657585,0.0593332238,0.323206216,0.00372228445,21.2999992,2.5 +1,0.92302829,0.0411622599,0.334667325,0.00301009137,21.3999996,2.5 +1,0.896843135,0.0445389263,0.277085006,0.00432557799,21.5,2.5 +1,0.920383215,0.0276278201,0.34768939,0.00635880651,21.6000004,2.5 +1,0.813381314,0.021076126,0.388304919,0.0148838433,21.7000008,2.5 +1,0.989215732,0.0253062099,0.34938854,0.0371292904,21.7999992,2.5 +1,0.438047081,-0.00843722653,0.435023665,0.0624179617,21.8999996,2.5 +4,1.36243296,0,0,0.299088269,22,2.5 +1,0.920021355,0.0821033865,0.248921603,0.00149254152,21,2.5999999 +1,0.933248281,0.0629008934,0.323010176,0.00249923044,21.1000004,2.5999999 +1,0.945809364,0.0577284247,0.289871812,0.00380860223,21.2000008,2.5999999 +1,0.95203346,0.0637362152,0.320265114,0.00601739809,21.2999992,2.5999999 +1,0.936293542,0.0388368852,0.319963872,0.00741130533,21.3999996,2.5999999 +1,0.953152955,0.0634999573,0.311207712,0.0111111598,21.5,2.5999999 +1,0.882328689,0.047919672,0.322431296,0.013092055,21.6000004,2.5999999 +1,0.933475494,0.0344267301,0.3864384,0.0205477476,21.7000008,2.5999999 +1,0.712576568,0.0657795221,0.345083803,0.0427678786,21.7999992,2.5999999 +1,0.934109569,0.239876956,0.37155056,0.0477166362,21.8999996,2.5999999 +4,0.181943566,0,0,0.101116613,22,2.5999999 +1,0.93167001,0.0654383376,0.239422888,0.00121155777,21,2.70000005 +1,0.94215405,0.0487725474,0.313873917,0.00243847445,21.1000004,2.70000005 +1,0.958599508,0.0507309735,0.329970568,0.00278674648,21.2000008,2.70000005 +1,0.95699954,0.0621079169,0.290419489,0.00150555035,21.2999992,2.70000005 +1,0.9765715,0.0523271076,0.278510302,0.00295598502,21.3999996,2.70000005 +1,0.929607391,0.0733969957,0.354332089,0.00335078989,21.5,2.70000005 +1,0.989146888,0.0591938309,0.33100155,0.00952141732,21.6000004,2.70000005 +1,0.905215144,0.0883295164,0.264687508,0.00849729311,21.7000008,2.70000005 +1,1.03584611,0.069338508,0.394273132,0.0318782143,21.7999992,2.70000005 +1,0.971692741,0.140851498,0.220822394,0.0446477085,21.8999996,2.70000005 +4,1.51776099,0,0,0.322308183,22,2.70000005 +1,0.932044089,0.0467360392,0.234735906,0.000888536917,21,2.79999995 +1,0.942102194,0.0301239509,0.302775413,0.0025376468,21.1000004,2.79999995 +1,0.951572955,0.0398414358,0.303348303,0.00297223357,21.2000008,2.79999995 +1,0.956995666,0.054311391,0.293771982,0.00432688883,21.2999992,2.79999995 +1,0.951987863,0.0598043986,0.271473289,0.00689129205,21.3999996,2.79999995 +1,0.954346538,0.081030421,0.330717653,0.0130551746,21.5,2.79999995 +1,0.895367861,0.0653949603,0.310958624,0.0161090717,21.6000004,2.79999995 +1,0.944780946,0.139351428,0.316086769,0.0210579764,21.7000008,2.79999995 +1,0.727944374,0.0344144106,0.366063118,0.0354349948,21.7999992,2.79999995 +1,0.969514191,0.00465497747,0.332443893,0.0449287854,21.8999996,2.79999995 +4,0.400240868,0,0,0.0858603194,22,2.79999995 +1,0.917130828,0.0289320052,0.232466131,0.000977318268,21,2.9000001 +1,0.926987886,0.0245227963,0.285352468,0.00223830622,21.1000004,2.9000001 +1,0.944245338,0.0385945775,0.247007281,0.00241179718,21.2000008,2.9000001 +1,0.933839321,0.0563697852,0.299641639,0.00329997437,21.2999992,2.9000001 +1,0.952225089,0.0670057163,0.29395619,0.00343343988,21.3999996,2.9000001 +1,0.922995329,0.0946965441,0.256982177,0.00262311124,21.5,2.9000001 +1,0.945766926,0.0855898783,0.30105114,0.00449087843,21.6000004,2.9000001 +1,0.859648407,0.156651407,0.335452974,0.0117924623,21.7000008,2.9000001 +1,0.997240067,0.0529076606,0.346650273,0.033592362,21.7999992,2.9000001 +1,0.522660553,0.214655355,0.403978378,0.0567222536,21.8999996,2.9000001 +4,1.37865853,0,0,0.303819954,22,2.9000001 +1,0.885054886,0.0145257693,0.233614266,0.00122817536,21,3 +1,0.897072434,-0.000486171019,0.268389344,0.00423538359,21.1000004,3 +1,0.906507373,0.0365524702,0.246935129,0.00407458749,21.2000008,3 +1,0.909514725,0.0366243646,0.269491315,0.00675160997,21.2999992,3 +1,0.901543677,0.0765403286,0.26058206,0.00455541816,21.3999996,3 +1,0.903665483,0.102798648,0.254803509,0.00493460288,21.5,3 +1,0.860080004,0.0950594991,0.274951816,0.0107688047,21.6000004,3 +1,0.897742391,0.166941285,0.328312904,0.0207768213,21.7000008,3 +1,0.716760814,0.139118135,0.26030457,0.0394410826,21.7999992,3 +1,0.899380565,0.360384226,0.393225402,0.0518739372,21.8999996,3 +4,-0.0192284379,0,0,0.114365138,22,3 +1,0.82891345,0.00815676805,0.237912327,0.00148911308,21,3.0999999 +1,0.835505128,-0.0091648018,0.251536399,0.00497022364,21.1000004,3.0999999 +1,0.850821614,0.0380908661,0.263222456,0.00180270325,21.2000008,3.0999999 +1,0.846375823,0.0494888574,0.215519175,0.00514646946,21.2999992,3.0999999 +1,0.85145998,0.0764902085,0.220656782,0.00124921987,21.3999996,3.0999999 +1,0.843042791,0.119464263,0.264139771,0.00159311283,21.5,3.0999999 +1,0.885245621,0.102153808,0.244760111,0.00694237882,21.6000004,3.0999999 +1,0.800096154,0.214095175,0.25855431,0.00555006927,21.7000008,3.0999999 +1,0.928735018,0.153952047,0.274206847,0.0192370191,21.7999992,3.0999999 +1,0.786798656,0.434976757,0.202847436,0.0327759758,21.8999996,3.0999999 +4,1.33949268,0,0,0.276404917,22,3.0999999 +1,0.759776592,0.00634082872,0.246771812,0.00205938751,21,3.20000005 +1,0.759489357,-0.0247607026,0.221393675,0.00606988231,21.1000004,3.20000005 +1,0.755717278,0.0271336809,0.208556607,0.00197860529,21.2000008,3.20000005 +1,0.770551622,0.0440972596,0.200546488,0.00557634979,21.2999992,3.20000005 +1,0.7659989,0.0724189803,0.226555496,0.00337898871,21.3999996,3.20000005 +1,0.776198447,0.0885396674,0.234399036,0.00852990896,21.5,3.20000005 +1,0.761358619,0.136330903,0.186859459,0.00788524933,21.6000004,3.20000005 +1,0.789419591,0.19803907,0.236695468,0.00994112529,21.7000008,3.20000005 +1,0.688252151,0.138381511,0.250874043,0.0208842028,21.7999992,3.20000005 +1,0.879873574,0.353162885,0.199835479,0.0388702527,21.8999996,3.20000005 +4,0.33830595,0,0,0.0906061828,22,3.20000005 +1,0.686747193,0.00878449809,0.264914304,0.00179569377,21,3.29999995 +1,0.680277407,-0.0016670553,0.172078684,0.00483201537,21.1000004,3.29999995 +1,0.672100842,0.0171880163,0.180824563,0.00113173015,21.2000008,3.29999995 +1,0.682305872,0.0449491739,0.207170621,0.00581225753,21.2999992,3.29999995 +1,0.704393744,0.0687398165,0.199628711,0.00181693491,21.3999996,3.29999995 +1,0.696521521,0.0967864022,0.192267135,0.00566945085,21.5,3.29999995 +1,0.72548002,0.117741086,0.192275301,0.00258365669,21.6000004,3.29999995 +1,0.721799731,0.207606301,0.190093964,0.00580829242,21.7000008,3.29999995 +1,0.828024447,0.0813614726,0.204543322,0.0257625505,21.7999992,3.29999995 +1,0.649768829,0.457122266,0.212048903,0.0428021848,21.8999996,3.29999995 +4,1.20628572,0,0,0.237780079,22,3.29999995 +1,0.608824193,0.0105550457,0.282141387,0.00160902878,21,3.4000001 +1,0.617999911,0.00583763979,0.156122386,0.0034632145,21.1000004,3.4000001 +1,0.611059308,0.0134350294,0.202000931,0.00245587714,21.2000008,3.4000001 +1,0.623594284,0.0102650234,0.198060751,0.00678121438,21.2999992,3.4000001 +1,0.625390112,0.0769038573,0.144043252,0.00505548669,21.3999996,3.4000001 +1,0.645119727,0.06921608,0.173142076,0.00570636056,21.5,3.4000001 +1,0.637989581,0.104846343,0.215557933,0.00349892001,21.6000004,3.4000001 +1,0.683379233,0.172545165,0.161477029,0.00341290375,21.7000008,3.4000001 +1,0.611899197,0.133190691,0.122134194,0.0139911901,21.7999992,3.4000001 +1,0.761289537,0.355944425,0.202946037,0.0280610546,21.8999996,3.4000001 +4,0.31069836,0,0,0.0714995563,22,3.4000001 +1,0.529455245,0.00361948204,0.290182412,0.00276229251,21,3.5 +1,0.552230477,-0.00635523908,0.199487254,0.00496290857,21.1000004,3.5 +1,0.567432523,0.021666022,0.172583655,0.000734061352,21.2000008,3.5 +1,0.563044488,0.0147755025,0.157977998,0.00442348979,21.2999992,3.5 +1,0.557397187,0.0589405559,0.17674607,0.0029272812,21.3999996,3.5 +1,0.574365616,0.0743162036,0.155130669,0.0053732302,21.5,3.5 +1,0.597063661,0.0741605163,0.155279815,0.00551094394,21.6000004,3.5 +1,0.593756914,0.192542851,0.161831498,0.00813872833,21.7000008,3.5 +1,0.693768144,0.061627306,0.13127701,0.0178918652,21.7999992,3.5 +1,0.604229391,0.428555518,0.149873778,0.0416257717,21.8999996,3.5 +4,1.03506541,0,0,0.189725697,22,3.5 +1,0.444397151,-0.00301487138,0.28797555,0.00407996634,21,3.5999999 +1,0.459502071,-0.0290992502,0.206788644,0.00547821494,21.1000004,3.5999999 +1,0.469670475,0.00796776358,0.130624503,0.00247230846,21.2000008,3.5999999 +1,0.483502239,0.0291561875,0.129744545,0.00425007287,21.2999992,3.5999999 +1,0.477535993,0.0350486413,0.209685698,0.00201004115,21.3999996,3.5999999 +1,0.508012414,0.0575263351,0.142577916,0.00622545741,21.5,3.5999999 +1,0.493324757,0.0854100138,0.106439419,0.0043561412,21.6000004,3.5999999 +1,0.547410131,0.0979063734,0.164642259,0.00555635011,21.7000008,3.5999999 +1,0.540768802,0.110966034,0.143131286,0.00709422212,21.7999992,3.5999999 +1,0.651079893,0.247500315,0.10140457,0.0169326514,21.8999996,3.5999999 +4,0.374237508,0,0,0.0611828864,22,3.5999999 +1,0.347209364,-0.00121558935,0.273582786,0.00531892013,21,3.70000005 +1,0.349000096,-0.0182550736,0.132850692,0.00492774695,21.1000004,3.70000005 +1,0.351741135,-0.0240993109,0.184169799,0.00388410338,21.2000008,3.70000005 +1,0.362424225,0.043852035,0.148903638,0.00483630551,21.2999992,3.70000005 +1,0.372877061,0.00903811399,0.128512308,0.00516650127,21.3999996,3.70000005 +1,0.399549097,0.0588311516,0.139069483,0.00371874007,21.5,3.70000005 +1,0.412905782,0.0477132276,0.170749485,0.00645893253,21.6000004,3.70000005 +1,0.426313221,0.0908358395,0.127659172,0.00955740083,21.7000008,3.70000005 +1,0.511046648,0.0267543253,0.0937915519,0.0151541773,21.7999992,3.70000005 +1,0.499714613,0.330422819,0.111749254,0.0335477367,21.8999996,3.70000005 +4,0.832763016,0,0,0.137185574,22,3.70000005 +1,0.247931689,0.00360902678,0.241362095,0.00592460902,21,3.79999995 +1,0.244182855,-0.00779652223,0.095488295,0.00423395634,21.1000004,3.79999995 +1,0.247896299,-0.035039328,0.173969969,0.00407966692,21.2000008,3.79999995 +1,0.261936694,0.0262853783,0.172194555,0.00289873895,21.2999992,3.79999995 +1,0.25869298,-0.000552670157,0.108775757,0.00577961141,21.3999996,3.79999995 +1,0.273390025,0.0394060574,0.136021361,0.00145763089,21.5,3.79999995 +1,0.296027362,0.0155848721,0.17885761,0.00825744029,21.6000004,3.79999995 +1,0.357715428,0.0569755249,0.0904269889,0.00522385677,21.7000008,3.79999995 +1,0.336901963,-0.00790892169,0.120053418,0.0125387311,21.7999992,3.79999995 +1,0.485709816,0.0925497264,0.115358643,0.0101369862,21.8999996,3.79999995 +4,0.431377053,0,0,0.0517913289,22,3.79999995 +1,0.155443728,0.00842429698,0.184239388,0.00431696419,21,3.9000001 +1,0.147886768,-0.0242797956,0.193320706,0.00766250445,21.1000004,3.9000001 +1,0.127401769,-0.00615156814,0.0882243365,0.00491517037,21.2000008,3.9000001 +1,0.125639424,0.00394805567,0.135023162,0.00380938663,21.2999992,3.9000001 +1,0.140242741,0.00365358428,0.174632505,0.008166763,21.3999996,3.9000001 +1,0.152210176,0.0216238145,0.148360968,0.00176133437,21.5,3.9000001 +1,0.161858916,-0.0172722992,0.109702572,0.0111070005,21.6000004,3.9000001 +1,0.176824823,0.0429622717,0.127786368,0.00387667329,21.7000008,3.9000001 +1,0.222552001,-0.0328241736,0.163127035,0.0180993006,21.7999992,3.9000001 +1,0.140028864,0.0451607928,0.108962275,0.0140406806,21.8999996,3.9000001 +4,0.471561313,0,0,0.0742404833,22,3.9000001 +2,0.0667856187,0.014241782,0.104572706,0.00450494839,21,4 +2,0,0,0.272909135,0.00893193204,21.1000004,4 +2,0,0,0.109006867,0.00612733886,21.2000008,4 +2,0,0,0.125983402,0.00354830595,21.2999992,4 +2,0,0,0.162771896,0.00720185693,21.3999996,4 +2,0,0,0.156480655,0.000872990408,21.5,4 +2,0,0,0.085267663,0.0127133057,21.6000004,4 +2,0,0,0.211242601,0.00321187382,21.7000008,4 +2,0,0,0.0697837025,0.0155652752,21.7999992,4 +2,0,0,0.118257962,0.00653170561,21.8999996,4 +2,0,0,0.0672080219,0.0249752384,22,4 diff --git a/img/data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_1.csv b/img/data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_1.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..695682f --- /dev/null +++ b/img/data/cylinder2d_low_resolution_outflow_refine_60s_1.csv @@ -0,0 +1,2243 @@ +geometry,ux,uy,p,knudsen,x,y +2,0,0,0.588287473,0.00660162605,0,0 +2,0,0,0.604167104,0.00733513152,0.200000003,0 +3,0.185603812,0,0.608453453,0.0218611378,0,0.200000003 +1,0.220916018,-0.0518572964,0.659817278,0.00753332349,0.200000003,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.674064636,0.0138510317,0.400000006,0 +1,0.247174218,0.0123331537,0.592912912,0.00979537889,0.400000006,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.559401155,0.00837750454,0.600000024,0 +1,0.236011744,-0.000640409417,0.617103338,0.00344672054,0.600000024,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.578750491,0.0118157687,0.800000012,0 +1,0.279323876,-0.0345672555,0.574252725,0.010846409,0.800000012,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.617573321,0.0118886186,1,0 +1,0.341542125,-0.0249426346,0.539797723,0.0104801608,1,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.531160712,0.0181706306,1.20000005,0 +1,0.375335634,-0.0428838022,0.617334962,0.00939846039,1.20000005,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.547331512,0.0236924812,1.39999998,0 +1,0.40732798,-0.0174780507,0.551531494,0.00968654919,1.39999998,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.545872211,0.0187867545,1.60000002,0 +1,0.449829221,0.0152328173,0.438577861,0.0120699778,1.60000002,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.349068582,0.0149017973,1.79999995,0 +1,0.514637351,-0.0553029627,0.452725738,0.0157299079,1.79999995,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.471569926,0.0269050058,2,0 +1,0.574032962,-0.0381015763,0.408425093,0.0180629287,2,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.465732783,0.0326451324,2.20000005,0 +1,0.629503429,-0.0415744148,0.444660336,0.0193564277,2.20000005,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.262438059,0.0261170622,2.4000001,0 +1,0.666000247,0.00891578663,0.37743485,0.0122631332,2.4000001,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.376869708,0.0343188494,2.5999999,0 +1,0.661707044,-0.0132333227,0.238831773,0.0179622862,2.5999999,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.262022018,0.0296255928,2.79999995,0 +1,0.681408465,0.0105358446,0.287037164,0.0174187087,2.79999995,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.243599981,0.0283324402,3,0 +1,0.691128194,-0.008349929,0.321298152,0.0181273427,3,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.287443042,0.0296438914,3.20000005,0 +1,0.677324891,0.0127278222,0.22560522,0.018407885,3.20000005,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.217499956,0.0269304775,3.4000001,0 +1,0.661657214,0.0200640131,0.201071203,0.0190432016,3.4000001,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.204736188,0.0247701406,3.5999999,0 +1,0.6432513,0.00600783061,0.254550129,0.018284427,3.5999999,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.248623803,0.0248196796,3.79999995,0 +1,0.627304494,0.0152460001,0.225697041,0.0200735629,3.79999995,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.221439391,0.0209667981,4,0 +1,0.602612317,0.0281664096,0.206648767,0.0202505346,4,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.194948927,0.0188046768,4.19999981,0 +1,0.561559021,0.0177080967,0.228973582,0.0192382019,4.19999981,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.221382424,0.0194610897,4.4000001,0 +1,0.51965344,0.0162285697,0.21356456,0.017975403,4.4000001,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.232885301,0.0170696434,4.5999999,0 +1,0.488468379,0.0308064409,0.204064831,0.0189209059,4.5999999,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.208992317,0.0119883101,4.80000019,0 +1,0.449185401,0.0258953199,0.239676178,0.0177658312,4.80000019,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.209792182,0.0119917979,5,0 +1,0.391197324,0.0201871265,0.227449477,0.0156714786,5,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.222612396,0.0125312367,5.19999981,0 +1,0.337957263,0.0234362669,0.190160275,0.0134850712,5.19999981,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.214647129,0.00919844583,5.4000001,0 +1,0.305325061,0.024852559,0.215170473,0.0130513916,5.4000001,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.214026451,0.00604485581,5.5999999,0 +1,0.272178471,0.0162046738,0.242887124,0.0118018417,5.5999999,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.219321832,0.00674546557,5.80000019,0 +1,0.228777394,0.0164363198,0.213837072,0.0104225036,5.80000019,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.220280185,0.00617955532,6,0 +1,0.19698374,0.0135245547,0.201692685,0.00847886037,6,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.228537187,0.00453357305,6.19999981,0 +1,0.186057374,0.00754499109,0.237100512,0.0085506374,6.19999981,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.24467431,0.00326144509,6.4000001,0 +1,0.178779483,0.00206522015,0.256825596,0.00791692734,6.4000001,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.261178643,0.00437621633,6.5999999,0 +1,0.172518894,-0.000748441613,0.251265138,0.0078368159,6.5999999,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.280152738,0.00459027616,6.80000019,0 +1,0.180246234,-0.00673871953,0.271860152,0.00824053865,6.80000019,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.304245025,0.00509185297,7,0 +1,0.200632036,-0.0117539167,0.311413258,0.00928819552,7,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.327404767,0.00572207244,7.19999981,0 +1,0.220152214,-0.0116192577,0.329997748,0.00926340744,7.19999981,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.345310509,0.00734559633,7.4000001,0 +1,0.236593738,-0.00995092653,0.337538272,0.0098089464,7.4000001,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.357781142,0.00785743818,7.5999999,0 +1,0.253560662,-0.00899370108,0.357385516,0.00979469158,7.5999999,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.369725734,0.00864436384,7.80000019,0 +1,0.267351776,-0.00716266502,0.374250501,0.00994938705,7.80000019,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.375456691,0.00903337169,8,0 +1,0.272931278,-0.00294791185,0.375064075,0.00927902665,8,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.374964982,0.00966252945,8.19999981,0 +1,0.272854209,-0.000663958606,0.372780502,0.00912294351,8.19999981,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.373492092,0.00957872625,8.39999962,0 +1,0.270896733,0.000863871013,0.374718487,0.00871278904,8.39999962,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.369198591,0.00962391123,8.60000038,0 +1,0.264950812,0.00374683389,0.371913135,0.00874435809,8.60000038,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.358631521,0.00912732072,8.80000019,0 +1,0.252231717,0.00740816025,0.359793484,0.00822144281,8.80000019,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.345411867,0.00879634451,9,0 +1,0.235218868,0.00927480031,0.344926685,0.00792436954,9,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.331570625,0.00779964868,9.19999981,0 +1,0.216853574,0.010857828,0.332347631,0.0074142809,9.19999981,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.31615445,0.00691278558,9.39999962,0 +1,0.196774349,0.011380937,0.318672955,0.00708204554,9.39999962,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.301466584,0.00594516145,9.60000038,0 +1,0.177355111,0.00924767833,0.301941782,0.00623995764,9.60000038,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.291848123,0.00557136163,9.80000019,0 +1,0.165114015,0.00449295389,0.289685011,0.00581608107,9.80000019,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.288535208,0.00513279811,10,0 +1,0.163124278,-0.000237866901,0.287746191,0.0056475359,10,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.290707707,0.00528628286,10.1999998,0 +1,0.169389546,-0.00502806157,0.291238606,0.00627523521,10.1999998,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.297111839,0.00577854877,10.3999996,0 +1,0.182361916,-0.00883554015,0.295554906,0.00685071386,10.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.306866974,0.00671980623,10.6000004,0 +1,0.201107964,-0.0107598314,0.303867012,0.00773843797,10.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.316570073,0.00734376162,10.8000002,0 +1,0.221180439,-0.00951857958,0.316279769,0.00823298376,10.8000002,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.323233366,0.0079323994,11,0 +1,0.23610194,-0.00639548618,0.324585617,0.00844800472,11,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.325805247,0.00828493759,11.1999998,0 +1,0.243107006,-0.00251560681,0.325359792,0.00823455304,11.1999998,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.325308949,0.00851315912,11.3999996,0 +1,0.244030967,0.000472399377,0.324426323,0.00819048285,11.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.32294789,0.0082808882,11.6000004,0 +1,0.240983263,0.00267639011,0.324096531,0.00811398122,11.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.319272965,0.0080252476,11.8000002,0 +1,0.234639004,0.00365868025,0.320617974,0.00797943398,11.8000002,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.315100402,0.00778786046,12,0 +1,0.226937518,0.00341647165,0.314743936,0.00760947634,12,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.312482536,0.00769101549,12.1999998,0 +1,0.221021295,0.00232660677,0.311684549,0.0073937471,12.1999998,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.311235338,0.00744197797,12.3999996,0 +1,0.217588887,0.0016567792,0.311761349,0.00723368395,12.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.31008485,0.00731952675,12.6000004,0 +1,0.214992091,0.00102025562,0.310845762,0.00713957753,12.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.309133708,0.00732239243,12.8000002,0 +1,0.212805644,0.000400894263,0.308652222,0.00699170446,12.8000002,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.30867973,0.00741278427,13,0 +1,0.21197772,-0.000184202741,0.308199942,0.00694574462,13,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.307838142,0.00737240259,13.1999998,0 +1,0.212378204,-0.000362004794,0.308502644,0.00691767549,13.1999998,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.30633086,0.00740087451,13.3999996,0 +1,0.212806895,-0.000370840629,0.30657497,0.00691433251,13.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.304310322,0.00745518506,13.6000004,0 +1,0.21288234,-0.000308672927,0.303809404,0.00687318388,13.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.301791728,0.00752681354,13.8000002,0 +1,0.213368133,-0.000588907336,0.302083164,0.00690859277,13.8000002,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.299268782,0.00750921806,14,0 +1,0.214751884,-0.000666050939,0.299506158,0.00696788915,14,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.297055125,0.00751096616,14.1999998,0 +1,0.216224864,-0.000531239784,0.296292663,0.00704592979,14.1999998,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.294551164,0.00755963055,14.3999996,0 +1,0.217197493,-0.000638477853,0.294835448,0.00707638776,14.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.292580098,0.0076337466,14.6000004,0 +1,0.218730345,-0.00105143001,0.293135136,0.00717370026,14.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.291770071,0.00761823263,14.8000002,0 +1,0.221021995,-0.000680203782,0.290379226,0.00729549164,14.8000002,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.290639371,0.00762941828,15,0 +1,0.222144172,-0.0004210771,0.290422589,0.00728885503,15,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.288711309,0.00778070511,15.1999998,0 +1,0.221881494,-0.000321562053,0.290789008,0.00727264211,15.1999998,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.287660778,0.00772551773,15.3999996,0 +1,0.22189185,0.000326084206,0.286607623,0.00725816237,15.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.285685837,0.007585024,15.6000004,0 +1,0.220855087,0.00126900885,0.283907384,0.00726479106,15.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.281618476,0.00763843348,15.8000002,0 +1,0.217303663,0.00127805513,0.284830302,0.00718937675,15.8000002,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.279150635,0.00753260357,16,0 +1,0.214225426,0.00165646675,0.279742599,0.0070590321,16,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.276275575,0.0071467571,16.2000008,0 +1,0.212053761,0.00174844288,0.272609442,0.00692916755,16.2000008,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.27139625,0.00730050215,16.3999996,0 +1,0.20846045,0.00159450294,0.273778379,0.0070575932,16.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.270957232,0.00711517362,16.6000004,0 +1,0.206551075,-6.9620095E-05,0.272903442,0.00674854452,16.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.268925071,0.00703899795,16.7999992,0 +1,0.206855565,0.000824705989,0.265928596,0.00690860162,16.7999992,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.266787916,0.00694373436,17,0 +1,0.206874564,-0.000717334857,0.266226143,0.00680061476,17,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.268844634,0.00735741667,17.2000008,0 +1,0.208331689,-0.00155381788,0.270954013,0.0071214973,17.2000008,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.268575072,0.0070570684,17.3999996,0 +1,0.211273685,-0.00141663419,0.268697351,0.0068766647,17.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.268420607,0.00745085347,17.6000004,0 +1,0.214426458,-0.00135650916,0.265682042,0.007329165,17.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.270897329,0.00743251434,17.7999992,0 +1,0.21744059,-0.00273567112,0.270661354,0.00707872817,17.7999992,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.270054191,0.00800117105,18,0 +1,0.219836593,-0.000307925511,0.274270475,0.00753771281,18,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.270569175,0.00722829765,18.2000008,0 +1,0.223130554,-0.00279792026,0.267596453,0.00691119907,18.2000008,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.268377602,0.00847260188,18.3999996,0 +1,0.225030079,0.000451215892,0.266080528,0.00785948616,18.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.270143598,0.00761934929,18.6000004,0 +1,0.2250956,-0.00168228778,0.272960186,0.00677461084,18.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.264990687,0.00852127373,18.7999992,0 +1,0.224890918,0.00141910324,0.268677324,0.00776200742,18.7999992,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.26231584,0.00719512627,19,0 +1,0.225597128,-0.000822699512,0.256643355,0.00666871946,19,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.263087869,0.0086454805,19.2000008,0 +1,0.226189986,0.00059829466,0.25995326,0.00807579327,19.2000008,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.256239146,0.00755903265,19.3999996,0 +1,0.223872364,-0.000960974838,0.2673392,0.00652617309,19.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.255259663,0.00871666055,19.6000004,0 +1,0.224872693,0.000202709401,0.251668632,0.00782297272,19.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.251977205,0.00727066584,19.7999992,0 +1,0.226274714,-0.00123902259,0.241673097,0.00636195717,19.7999992,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.247683182,0.00953073427,20,0 +1,0.224461928,0.00414765114,0.257681191,0.0086122239,20,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.24648641,0.00655826461,20.2000008,0 +1,0.227715984,-0.0098855542,0.25036332,0.00543355476,20.2000008,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.237918109,0.0111207152,20.3999996,0 +1,0.234125167,0.00201123673,0.228545293,0.00933224335,20.3999996,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.241036221,0.00788632501,20.6000004,0 +1,0.23484388,0.00307670608,0.236757129,0.00745262858,20.6000004,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.249826759,0.00819154177,20.7999992,0 +1,0.238800585,-0.00898455363,0.255059719,0.00721695274,20.7999992,0.200000003 +2,0,0,0.169382587,0.0134740938,21,0 +1,0.249018803,-0.00759227807,0.213767305,0.0118210232,21,0.200000003 +2,0.0215945877,-0.0118778283,0.0183496699,0.00227228249,21.2000008,0 +1,0.255782396,0.0333084352,0.173217461,0.00690357294,21.2000008,0.200000003 +3,0.352171332,0,0.646692812,0.0346080773,0,0.400000006 +1,0.372579128,-0.0910468251,0.623738527,0.00550287589,0.200000003,0.400000006 +1,0.388267666,0.013279845,0.567873895,0.0088165449,0.400000006,0.400000006 +1,0.422845751,-0.0377864987,0.622475266,0.00391156925,0.600000024,0.400000006 +1,0.478228003,-0.0860715881,0.609510899,0.00797115173,0.800000012,0.400000006 +1,0.49080956,-0.0610573255,0.566231072,0.00477755675,1,0.400000006 +1,0.519684255,-0.0851954892,0.559141159,0.00341305812,1.20000005,0.400000006 +1,0.595320582,-0.0812329501,0.513651669,0.00462105637,1.39999998,0.400000006 +1,0.707165658,-0.066154018,0.459324539,0.0109410351,1.60000002,0.400000006 +1,0.793118417,-0.117455229,0.514452279,0.00976539589,1.79999995,0.400000006 +1,0.855700672,-0.141704679,0.42004618,0.00561368233,2,0.400000006 +1,0.892196238,-0.0278141201,0.307538033,0.00583921839,2.20000005,0.400000006 +1,0.943857074,-0.0586383305,0.355375826,0.0095088575,2.4000001,0.400000006 +1,0.999345601,-0.0244836044,0.314526886,0.00619352702,2.5999999,0.400000006 +1,1.01882637,-0.015351749,0.29438436,0.00648197532,2.79999995,0.400000006 +1,1.03346133,0.00166800222,0.224219859,0.00828874391,3,0.400000006 +1,1.04229236,0.00436511217,0.234906986,0.00831781048,3.20000005,0.400000006 +1,1.05482376,0.0339731909,0.250785619,0.00846066885,3.4000001,0.400000006 +1,1.04899156,0.0184496939,0.228516966,0.0087682493,3.5999999,0.400000006 +1,1.02707589,0.0383811556,0.203927442,0.0100403773,3.79999995,0.400000006 +1,1.01127839,0.0539150462,0.211213827,0.0109050358,4,0.400000006 +1,0.999898732,0.0573670007,0.221356496,0.0130772721,4.19999981,0.400000006 +1,0.963811338,0.0545932986,0.23054862,0.0129110077,4.4000001,0.400000006 +1,0.90781796,0.08068344,0.212982222,0.0138576971,4.5999999,0.400000006 +1,0.852131426,0.086417973,0.200655892,0.015488755,4.80000019,0.400000006 +1,0.799766898,0.0810213313,0.220618993,0.0160971899,5,0.400000006 +1,0.733663321,0.0801977888,0.233753577,0.0143849226,5.19999981,0.400000006 +1,0.653642893,0.0831848606,0.212217033,0.0145063782,5.4000001,0.400000006 +1,0.583209217,0.0686199889,0.199377269,0.0140154855,5.5999999,0.400000006 +1,0.53440994,0.0576432794,0.220393792,0.0126434611,5.80000019,0.400000006 +1,0.491612375,0.0444970578,0.233421788,0.0107192351,6,0.400000006 +1,0.450639755,0.0295569748,0.22349903,0.0108868042,6.19999981,0.400000006 +1,0.428986043,0.00982996915,0.230587304,0.00959799998,6.4000001,0.400000006 +1,0.432277799,-0.00751121761,0.261631638,0.00940409955,6.5999999,0.400000006 +1,0.445651591,-0.0227800868,0.285503238,0.00918297376,6.80000019,0.400000006 +1,0.462976038,-0.0325898938,0.299341947,0.0104150921,7,0.400000006 +1,0.487517685,-0.0353722461,0.322856873,0.01058322,7.19999981,0.400000006 +1,0.515458882,-0.0321729966,0.348856628,0.0107044978,7.4000001,0.400000006 +1,0.536484957,-0.0249607954,0.362478495,0.0103544807,7.5999999,0.400000006 +1,0.547515273,-0.0151942801,0.367788643,0.0106561696,7.80000019,0.400000006 +1,0.550166309,-0.00351325772,0.375860095,0.010072968,8,0.400000006 +1,0.543894589,0.00480903732,0.381109625,0.00992285926,8.19999981,0.400000006 +1,0.527567923,0.012321813,0.376828939,0.00952245388,8.39999962,0.400000006 +1,0.504818857,0.0204899274,0.369048089,0.00939130131,8.60000038,0.400000006 +1,0.479302287,0.0286730677,0.36261487,0.00872661825,8.80000019,0.400000006 +1,0.449659109,0.0339745358,0.351834834,0.00840074476,9,0.400000006 +1,0.415908635,0.0379924886,0.333279163,0.00784950703,9.19999981,0.400000006 +1,0.383777231,0.0370918848,0.313876748,0.00744673517,9.39999962,0.400000006 +1,0.358260721,0.0285913069,0.299761117,0.00657688361,9.60000038,0.400000006 +1,0.340617239,0.0136408554,0.289416045,0.00594408344,9.80000019,0.400000006 +1,0.333959669,-0.00246956898,0.282141,0.00529876724,10,0.400000006 +1,0.341969639,-0.0183738805,0.282891333,0.00592356315,10.1999998,0.400000006 +1,0.362911642,-0.0310273822,0.292833239,0.00625987677,10.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.390914679,-0.0371022783,0.305043072,0.006794204,10.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.420544833,-0.0333084539,0.314676851,0.00726679061,10.8000002,0.400000006 +1,0.446408242,-0.0223414414,0.322709471,0.00769159244,11,0.400000006 +1,0.462228715,-0.00868267938,0.328723878,0.00744126877,11.1999998,0.400000006 +1,0.464835376,0.00276436727,0.328752697,0.00728501426,11.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.45773536,0.0104152001,0.323210716,0.00729017379,11.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.447550684,0.0131204305,0.318052143,0.0072543975,11.8000002,0.400000006 +1,0.437903076,0.011830383,0.315745473,0.00701901643,12,0.400000006 +1,0.429107517,0.00875277538,0.313109726,0.00690057734,12.1999998,0.400000006 +1,0.421745926,0.00642521493,0.309818983,0.00680624321,12.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.416972399,0.00417670375,0.309002042,0.00678440882,12.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.414198041,0.00225906121,0.31003961,0.00666987151,12.8000002,0.400000006 +1,0.411591679,0.00100847788,0.309612244,0.0066059269,13,0.400000006 +1,0.408711851,0.000500509108,0.307895303,0.0065052514,13.1999998,0.400000006 +1,0.406542361,-4.62311691E-05,0.306657583,0.00639939588,13.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.405370861,-0.00038988053,0.305122226,0.00620383956,13.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.404414445,-0.0010479599,0.302372217,0.00605062814,13.8000002,0.400000006 +1,0.403864145,-0.00188384543,0.299280643,0.00593745522,14,0.400000006 +1,0.40496695,-0.00253505376,0.296434313,0.00596052036,14.1999998,0.400000006 +1,0.407803744,-0.00305461301,0.294042736,0.00592416804,14.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.411255598,-0.00390092027,0.292455763,0.00597144524,14.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.414981633,-0.00352207851,0.291184932,0.00619421992,14.8000002,0.400000006 +1,0.418823898,-0.0021715411,0.289870501,0.00631591352,15,0.400000006 +1,0.421225727,-0.000568243559,0.289256066,0.00630534254,15.1999998,0.400000006 +1,0.421046883,0.00144357875,0.288468242,0.00645532459,15.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.418506563,0.00408802228,0.286160707,0.00655753119,15.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.414300501,0.0054320069,0.282785237,0.0063305567,15.8000002,0.400000006 +1,0.409457535,0.005944971,0.279166937,0.00638372358,16,0.400000006 +1,0.404210716,0.00541730272,0.276401907,0.00638163928,16.2000008,0.400000006 +1,0.400146395,0.00407311553,0.272913069,0.00612258306,16.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.398702174,0.00147806888,0.268133044,0.00601113215,16.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.397894412,0.000694158254,0.268386632,0.00639059301,16.7999992,0.400000006 +1,0.399142087,-0.00333570829,0.268813193,0.00604169397,17,0.400000006 +1,0.402837604,-0.00398269948,0.265474945,0.0063530663,17.2000008,0.400000006 +1,0.406398475,-0.00466423947,0.267277241,0.00628744438,17.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.410788119,-0.00626559369,0.271146983,0.00663146796,17.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.415396839,-0.00644361693,0.26954478,0.00615355512,17.7999992,0.400000006 +1,0.419357896,-0.00274590449,0.26870808,0.0067124893,18,0.400000006 +1,0.421962559,-0.00538767641,0.271711588,0.00613100315,18.2000008,0.400000006 +1,0.422528863,-0.00146981317,0.272660404,0.00675327703,18.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.424528062,-0.00158555619,0.26530686,0.00579300942,18.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.424332291,0.0028591291,0.265564084,0.00702270446,18.7999992,0.400000006 +1,0.422691345,-0.00225294917,0.268209398,0.005653637,19,0.400000006 +1,0.421544909,0.00160982634,0.260368407,0.00693275454,19.2000008,0.400000006 +1,0.419704616,0.00179081049,0.254863977,0.00523440214,19.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.418737173,-0.000291432778,0.256298423,0.00697524752,19.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.417425394,-0.00308840605,0.255202264,0.00508661056,19.7999992,0.400000006 +1,0.422283351,0.00183927128,0.244054735,0.00736469729,20,0.400000006 +1,0.425705999,-0.00832317304,0.24211888,0.00513534015,20.2000008,0.400000006 +1,0.418129712,-0.0102548851,0.255620539,0.0066837091,20.3999996,0.400000006 +1,0.440164506,0.00246374286,0.225678205,0.00767362164,20.6000004,0.400000006 +1,0.441465855,-0.0244033467,0.226527989,0.00469087809,20.7999992,0.400000006 +1,0.434412539,-0.00272023957,0.262149155,0.00780223031,21,0.400000006 +1,0.460020125,-0.013888672,0.116844229,0.00633041793,21.2000008,0.400000006 +3,0.499702573,0,0.586354315,0.0502462313,0,0.600000024 +1,0.480159014,-0.0503329709,0.568178773,0.0067102476,0.200000003,0.600000024 +1,0.46915397,-0.0452676155,0.660092533,0.00917418022,0.400000006,0.600000024 +1,0.535769165,-0.0967078432,0.59312129,0.00714432588,0.600000024,0.600000024 +1,0.543197632,-0.0841195583,0.586295664,0.00559928268,0.800000012,0.600000024 +1,0.558111668,-0.102905162,0.623733401,0.00562463468,1,0.600000024 +1,0.678106666,-0.138684809,0.499208361,0.00902222004,1.20000005,0.600000024 +1,0.766201377,-0.167750403,0.522888839,0.0129148839,1.39999998,0.600000024 +1,0.865899384,-0.242696136,0.551420212,0.0102844648,1.60000002,0.600000024 +1,0.949711561,-0.130013406,0.384473592,0.00379390293,1.79999995,0.600000024 +1,0.988354027,-0.192144662,0.403614759,0.00637442386,2,0.600000024 +1,1.04598284,-0.067222856,0.310103923,0.0111777466,2.20000005,0.600000024 +1,1.1110462,-0.140409291,0.284667611,0.010250859,2.4000001,0.600000024 +1,1.1616143,-0.0490897559,0.324212074,0.00919330399,2.5999999,0.600000024 +1,1.19957089,-0.0517999902,0.243145078,0.0078910701,2.79999995,0.600000024 +1,1.21985853,-0.00704140868,0.191190943,0.00734515116,3,0.600000024 +1,1.22456026,-0.00706348056,0.2629731,0.00568336761,3.20000005,0.600000024 +1,1.23781967,0.0202312935,0.22630848,0.00644924631,3.4000001,0.600000024 +1,1.24812174,0.0283023287,0.164610431,0.00636058347,3.5999999,0.600000024 +1,1.24941206,0.0462657437,0.22548154,0.0067251334,3.79999995,0.600000024 +1,1.24375093,0.0512299016,0.243145213,0.00466477964,4,0.600000024 +1,1.2357614,0.080662325,0.170733765,0.00648181932,4.19999981,0.600000024 +1,1.22009873,0.0961271375,0.185460478,0.00880405679,4.4000001,0.600000024 +1,1.19902599,0.111596651,0.239239648,0.00862069242,4.5999999,0.600000024 +1,1.16303062,0.133162603,0.209674239,0.00783075299,4.80000019,0.600000024 +1,1.10665429,0.152956903,0.185256422,0.0109658185,5,0.600000024 +1,1.04144418,0.154742435,0.215799242,0.012139624,5.19999981,0.600000024 +1,0.9767344,0.14877747,0.220559031,0.0112618851,5.4000001,0.600000024 +1,0.905339301,0.138186231,0.204132274,0.0103123393,5.5999999,0.600000024 +1,0.831966102,0.120041944,0.215501696,0.0112161422,5.80000019,0.600000024 +1,0.769800067,0.0927531719,0.226759493,0.00998186041,6,0.600000024 +1,0.725783229,0.0596448518,0.223047554,0.00852373149,6.19999981,0.600000024 +1,0.699200094,0.0245892312,0.236073732,0.00692815846,6.4000001,0.600000024 +1,0.688140869,-0.00950856693,0.266891629,0.00715292292,6.5999999,0.600000024 +1,0.689285755,-0.0364473648,0.286493629,0.00660853926,6.80000019,0.600000024 +1,0.702089071,-0.0547121279,0.301096231,0.00690564746,7,0.600000024 +1,0.725572169,-0.0618123077,0.327789634,0.00696202228,7.19999981,0.600000024 +1,0.753852248,-0.0580976233,0.351819843,0.00800522324,7.4000001,0.600000024 +1,0.777887642,-0.0434474982,0.361824721,0.00787387136,7.5999999,0.600000024 +1,0.793950558,-0.0237092692,0.369341135,0.00815683976,7.80000019,0.600000024 +1,0.801637173,-0.00143663294,0.377855152,0.00826512743,8,0.600000024 +1,0.798635066,0.0180396382,0.379879028,0.00925408024,8.19999981,0.600000024 +1,0.78218019,0.0357606672,0.377095997,0.00982640032,8.39999962,0.600000024 +1,0.75384593,0.0500571541,0.372568846,0.0102760326,8.60000038,0.600000024 +1,0.717781544,0.0628724173,0.364042103,0.0101913614,8.80000019,0.600000024 +1,0.677042782,0.0717595816,0.351011276,0.0101597533,9,0.600000024 +1,0.634125769,0.0759284496,0.333545804,0.00939977355,9.19999981,0.600000024 +1,0.592501581,0.0705571547,0.3130638