From a11a7f6715358e234e1beaf1725da88e49ff6892 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Adrian Kummerlaender Date: Sun, 10 Feb 2019 19:36:16 +0100 Subject: Expand cylinder2d evaluation --- content.tex | 11 +- img/cylinder2d_high_res_comparsion.tikz | 94 ++ ...ingle_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv | 1602 ++++++++++++++++++++ ...level_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv | 1602 ++++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 3308 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) create mode 100644 img/cylinder2d_high_res_comparsion.tikz create mode 100644 img/data/cylinder2d_single_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv create mode 100644 img/data/cylinder2d_two_level_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv diff --git a/content.tex b/content.tex index dff85a5..0111c9d 100644 --- a/content.tex +++ b/content.tex @@ -1133,7 +1133,8 @@ Klar zu erkennen ist, dass die Simulation auf dem verfeinerten Gitter über alle \bigskip -Als weiteren Vergleich betrachten wir die entscheidenden maximalen Widerstands- und Auftriebskoeffizienten \(\widehat{c_w}\) bzw. \(\widehat{c_a}\) eines uniform mit \(N=40\), d.h. der maximalen lokalen Auflösung unseres problembewusst verfeinerten Gitters entsprechend, aufgelösten Gitters. +Das diesen Resultaten zugrundeliegende Gitter orientiert sich in der Anzahl seiner Zellen an einem uniform aufgelösten Gitter, welches knapp an der Grenze zur Divergenz im Ausflussgebiet arbeitet. Die im Vergleich dazu sehr guten Ergebnisse des optimierten Gitters sind also nicht zu überraschend. +Als weiteren Vergleich betrachten wir deshalb die entscheidenden maximalen Widerstands- und Auftriebskoeffizienten \(\widehat{c_w}\) bzw. \(\widehat{c_a}\) eines uniform mit \(N=40\), d.h. der maximalen lokalen Auflösung unseres problembewusst verfeinerten Gitters entsprechend, aufgelösten Gitters. Auch im Vergleich mit diesem 145314 Knoten umfassenden Gitter bewähren sich die, mit nur etwa einem Zehntel der Knoten gewonnenen, Ergebnisse der verfeinerten Simulation: \begin{figure}[h] @@ -1160,10 +1161,18 @@ Knotenanzahl & 145314 & 13454 & \\ \noindent Tatsächlich ist der Fehler des verfeinerten Gitters für Widerstandskoeffizient und Druckdifferenz sogar kleiner als der des uniformen Gitters mit ungleich mehr Knoten. +\bigskip + +Wir haben an dieser Stelle also auch im formalen Vergleich bestätigt, dass sich Gitterverfeinerung zur besseren Verteilung beschränkter Rechenressourcen einsetzen lässt. +Die bestimmten Vergleichswerte bestehen bei geeigneter Variation der lokalen Gitterweiten auch in Konkurrenz mit uniformen Gittern, die auf der ganzen Simulationsdomäne der feinsten Gitterweite des heterogenen Gitters entsprechend aufgelöst sind. Es stellt sich daher die Frage, ob dieser klare Vorteil auch auf höher aufgelöste Gitter übertragen werden kann und sich die Ergebnisse in vergleichbarem Maße verbessern. + +Dazu sehen wir in Abbildung~\ref{fig:142000nodes} die charakteristischen Messwerte des uniformen \(N=40\) Gitters sowie eines problembezogen varierten Gitters mit gleicher Knotenanzahl. + \begin{figure}[H] \centering \input{img/cylinder2d_high_res_comparsion.tikz} \caption{Aerodynamische Koeffizienten in Gittern mit \(\sim 142000\) Knoten} +\label{fig:142000nodes} \end{figure} \newpage diff --git a/img/cylinder2d_high_res_comparsion.tikz b/img/cylinder2d_high_res_comparsion.tikz new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a1f8b59 --- /dev/null +++ b/img/cylinder2d_high_res_comparsion.tikz @@ -0,0 +1,94 @@ +\begin{tikzpicture} +\pgfplotstableread[col sep=comma]{img/data/cylinder2d_optimized_refinement_n17_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv}\refined +\pgfplotstableread[col sep=comma]{img/data/cylinder2d_unrefined_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv}\uniform + +\begin{axis}[ + scale only axis, + height=5cm, + width=0.9*\textwidth, + legend cell align=left, + legend pos=south east, + grid=both, + domain=0:16, + xmin=0, xmax=16, + ylabel={Widerstandskoeffizient}, + ylabel absolute, every axis y label/.append style={yshift=0.4cm} +] +\addplot[thick,color=black]{3.23}; +\addlegendentry {\(\widehat{c_w} := 3.23\)}; +\addplot[ + color=blue!50!white, + very thin +] table [ + x expr=\thisrow{time}, y=drag +] {\uniform}; +\addplot[ + color=green!70!black, +] table [ + x expr=8*\thisrow{time}, y=drag +] {\refined}; +\end{axis} + +\begin{axis}[ + scale only axis, + yshift=-6cm, + height=5cm, + width=0.9*\textwidth, + legend cell align=left, + legend pos=south west, + grid=both, + domain=0:16, + xmin=0, xmax=16, + ylabel={Auftriebskoeffizient}, + ylabel absolute, every axis y label/.append style={yshift=0.4cm} +] +\addplot[thick,color=black]{1.0}; +\addlegendentry {\(\widehat{c_a} := 1\)}; +\addplot[ + color=blue!50!white, + very thin +] table [ + x expr=\thisrow{time}, y=lift +] {\uniform}; +\addplot[ + color=green!70!black, +] table [ + x expr=8*\thisrow{time}, y=lift +] {\refined}; +\end{axis} + +\begin{axis}[ + scale only axis, + yshift=-12cm, + height=5cm, + width=0.9*\textwidth, + legend cell align=left, + legend pos=south east, + grid=both, + domain=0:16, + xmin=0, xmax=16, + xlabel={Simulierte physikalische Zeit}, + ylabel={Druckdifferenz}, + x unit=s, + y unit=N/m^2, + ylabel absolute, every axis y label/.append style={yshift=0.4cm} +] +\addplot[ + color=blue!50!white, + very thin +] table [ + x expr=\thisrow{time}, y=deltap +] {\uniform}; +\addlegendentry {Uniformes \(N=40\) Gitter}; +\addplot[ + color=green!70!black, +] table [ + x expr=8*\thisrow{time}, y=deltap +] {\refined}; +\addlegendentry {Problembezogen verfeinertes \(N=17\) Gitter}; +\addplot[thick,color=black]{2.48}; +\addlegendentry {\(\Delta P := 2.48\)}; +\end{axis} + +\end{tikzpicture} + diff --git a/img/data/cylinder2d_single_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv b/img/data/cylinder2d_single_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1805275 --- /dev/null +++ b/img/data/cylinder2d_single_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv @@ -0,0 +1,1602 @@ +time,drag,lift,deltap +0,0,0,0 +0.005,2.05624e-06,-5.88419e-09,1.25954e-06 +0.01,1.29454e-05,-2.46559e-08,7.77495e-06 +0.015,3.34183e-05,-5.54153e-08,1.98279e-05 +0.02,6.38997e-05,-9.87722e-08,3.75545e-05 +0.025,0.000104722,-1.53677e-07,6.10543e-05 +0.03,0.000156171,-2.22986e-07,9.04105e-05 +0.035,0.000221264,-3.03411e-07,0.000127369 +0.04,0.000299812,-3.95966e-07,0.00017164 +0.045,0.000389729,-4.97211e-07,0.000221918 +0.05,0.000491378,-6.09529e-07,0.000278373 +0.055,0.000604869,-7.34116e-07,0.00034102 +0.06,0.000730303,-8.69123e-07,0.000409868 +0.065,0.000866841,-1.01295e-06,0.000484356 +0.07,0.00101158,-1.16731e-06,0.00056274 +0.075,0.00116872,-1.33249e-06,0.000647557 +0.08,0.00133798,-1.5099e-06,0.00073854 +0.085,0.00151957,-1.69724e-06,0.000835782 +0.09,0.00171363,-1.89457e-06,0.000939313 +0.095,0.00192068,-2.10047e-06,0.0010494 +0.1,0.00214366,-2.31797e-06,0.00116776 +0.105,0.00238071,-2.5429e-06,0.00129313 +0.11,0.0026307,-2.77652e-06,0.00142485 +0.115,0.00289387,-3.01768e-06,0.00156302 +0.12,0.00317023,-3.26577e-06,0.00170762 +0.125,0.00345961,-3.52278e-06,0.00185851 +0.13,0.00376053,-3.78664e-06,0.00201479 +0.135,0.00407157,-4.05838e-06,0.00217561 +0.14,0.0043964,-4.33812e-06,0.00234319 +0.145,0.00473423,-4.62443e-06,0.00251699 +0.15,0.00508535,-4.91946e-06,0.00269715 +0.155,0.00544987,-5.22111e-06,0.00288371 +0.16,0.00582874,-5.52862e-06,0.0030772 +0.165,0.00622434,-5.84222e-06,0.00327899 +0.17,0.00663385,-6.16167e-06,0.0034873 +0.175,0.00705709,-6.48536e-06,0.00370204 +0.18,0.00749412,-6.81411e-06,0.00392321 +0.185,0.00794488,-7.14725e-06,0.00415076 +0.19,0.0084089,-7.48368e-06,0.00438438 +0.195,0.00888446,-7.82389e-06,0.00462304 +0.2,0.00937151,-8.16896e-06,0.00486675 +0.205,0.00987286,-8.51878e-06,0.00511718 +0.21,0.0103876,-8.87254e-06,0.0053737 +0.215,0.0109159,-9.22865e-06,0.0056365 +0.22,0.0114582,-9.5881e-06,0.00590568 +0.225,0.0120157,-9.95074e-06,0.006182 +0.23,0.0125898,-1.03154e-05,0.00646627 +0.235,0.0131774,-1.06811e-05,0.00675655 +0.24,0.0137791,-1.10471e-05,0.00705323 +0.245,0.0143948,-1.14137e-05,0.00735616 +0.25,0.0150243,-1.17807e-05,0.00766524 +0.255,0.0156667,-1.2148e-05,0.00798002 +0.26,0.0163206,-1.25144e-05,0.00829953 +0.265,0.016987,-1.2881e-05,0.00862447 +0.27,0.0176676,-1.32472e-05,0.00895584 +0.275,0.0183616,-1.36125e-05,0.0092931 +0.28,0.0190693,-1.39772e-05,0.00963647 +0.285,0.0197911,-1.43398e-05,0.00998618 +0.29,0.0205285,-1.46996e-05,0.010343 +0.295,0.0212819,-1.50566e-05,0.0107072 +0.3,0.0220484,-1.54095e-05,0.011077 +0.305,0.0228291,-1.5758e-05,0.0114531 +0.31,0.0236236,-1.6101e-05,0.0118352 +0.315,0.0244315,-1.64389e-05,0.012223 +0.32,0.0252519,-1.67711e-05,0.0126161 +0.325,0.0260836,-1.70975e-05,0.0130138 +0.33,0.0269284,-1.74176e-05,0.0134171 +0.335,0.0277869,-1.77307e-05,0.0138264 +0.34,0.0286587,-1.80365e-05,0.0142413 +0.345,0.0295441,-1.83343e-05,0.0146622 +0.35,0.0304437,-1.86237e-05,0.0150894 +0.355,0.0313587,-1.89035e-05,0.0155235 +0.36,0.0322888,-1.9172e-05,0.0159643 +0.365,0.0332317,-1.94289e-05,0.0164104 +0.37,0.0341885,-1.96729e-05,0.0168626 +0.375,0.0351586,-1.99041e-05,0.0173204 +0.38,0.0361417,-2.01217e-05,0.0177837 +0.385,0.0371367,-2.03242e-05,0.0182518 +0.39,0.0381429,-2.05113e-05,0.0187243 +0.395,0.0391623,-2.06833e-05,0.0192025 +0.4,0.0401949,-2.08384e-05,0.0196864 +0.405,0.0412405,-2.09757e-05,0.0201757 +0.41,0.0422995,-2.1094e-05,0.0206707 +0.415,0.0433725,-2.11923e-05,0.021172 +0.42,0.0444606,-2.12695e-05,0.02168 +0.425,0.0455628,-2.13238e-05,0.022194 +0.43,0.0466774,-2.13535e-05,0.0227132 +0.435,0.0478056,-2.13579e-05,0.0232382 +0.44,0.0489466,-2.13354e-05,0.0237686 +0.445,0.0500999,-2.12849e-05,0.024304 +0.45,0.0512644,-2.12054e-05,0.024844 +0.455,0.0524403,-2.10956e-05,0.0253885 +0.46,0.0536293,-2.09543e-05,0.0259387 +0.465,0.0548309,-2.07797e-05,0.0264942 +0.47,0.0560452,-2.05703e-05,0.0270551 +0.475,0.0572726,-2.03246e-05,0.0276217 +0.48,0.058514,-2.00402e-05,0.0281945 +0.485,0.05977,-1.97148e-05,0.0287738 +0.49,0.0610391,-1.93466e-05,0.0293587 +0.495,0.0623204,-1.8934e-05,0.0299488 +0.5,0.063615,-1.84742e-05,0.0305446 +0.505,0.0649218,-1.79655e-05,0.0311457 +0.51,0.0662405,-1.74058e-05,0.0317516 +0.515,0.06757,-1.67928e-05,0.032362 +0.52,0.0689111,-1.6125e-05,0.0329773 +0.525,0.0702652,-1.54e-05,0.0335984 +0.53,0.0716315,-1.46151e-05,0.0342247 +0.535,0.0730104,-1.37676e-05,0.0348566 +0.54,0.0744024,-1.28549e-05,0.0354944 +0.545,0.0758085,-1.1874e-05,0.0361386 +0.55,0.0772286,-1.08216e-05,0.0367892 +0.555,0.0786614,-9.69438e-06,0.0374455 +0.56,0.0801065,-8.48948e-06,0.0381073 +0.565,0.0815647,-7.20395e-06,0.038775 +0.57,0.083035,-5.83445e-06,0.0394481 +0.575,0.084517,-4.37778e-06,0.0401263 +0.58,0.0860099,-2.83073e-06,0.0408094 +0.585,0.087515,-1.18999e-06,0.0414981 +0.59,0.0890332,5.47656e-07,0.0421929 +0.595,0.0905637,2.38636e-06,0.0428934 +0.6,0.0921073,4.32993e-06,0.0436003 +0.605,0.0936644,6.38214e-06,0.0443136 +0.61,0.095236,8.54758e-06,0.045034 +0.615,0.0968217,1.08308e-05,0.0457614 +0.62,0.0984201,1.3236e-05,0.0464949 +0.625,0.100032,1.57674e-05,0.0472348 +0.63,0.101657,1.84297e-05,0.0479814 +0.635,0.103294,2.12274e-05,0.0487342 +0.64,0.104944,2.41646e-05,0.049493 +0.645,0.106606,2.72458e-05,0.0502578 +0.65,0.108281,3.04756e-05,0.0510295 +0.655,0.10997,3.38594e-05,0.0518084 +0.66,0.111673,3.74019e-05,0.0525943 +0.665,0.113389,4.11081e-05,0.0533878 +0.67,0.115121,4.49835e-05,0.0541893 +0.675,0.116868,4.90334e-05,0.0549993 +0.68,0.11863,5.32637e-05,0.0558174 +0.685,0.120407,5.76798e-05,0.0566433 +0.69,0.122198,6.22868e-05,0.0574775 +0.695,0.124004,6.70906e-05,0.0583198 +0.7,0.125824,7.20964e-05,0.0591701 +0.705,0.127658,7.73097e-05,0.0600284 +0.71,0.129507,8.27355e-05,0.0608948 +0.715,0.131371,8.83793e-05,0.0617704 +0.72,0.13325,9.42471e-05,0.0626553 +0.725,0.135146,0.000100344,0.0635496 +0.73,0.137058,0.000106677,0.064454 +0.735,0.138988,0.00011325,0.065369 +0.74,0.140936,0.00012007,0.0662949 +0.745,0.142901,0.000127143,0.0672316 +0.75,0.144883,0.000134474,0.0681788 +0.755,0.146884,0.000142068,0.0691372 +0.76,0.148901,0.00014993,0.0701068 +0.765,0.150937,0.000158066,0.0710875 +0.77,0.152989,0.000166481,0.0720793 +0.775,0.15506,0.000175179,0.0730829 +0.78,0.157149,0.000184164,0.0740993 +0.785,0.159259,0.000193441,0.0751285 +0.79,0.161388,0.000203015,0.076171 +0.795,0.163538,0.00021289,0.0772275 +0.8,0.16571,0.000223069,0.0782985 +0.805,0.167905,0.000233558,0.0793846 +0.81,0.170121,0.000244358,0.0804854 +0.815,0.172358,0.000255474,0.0816012 +0.82,0.174619,0.000266907,0.0827326 +0.825,0.176901,0.00027866,0.0838796 +0.83,0.179207,0.000290734,0.0850424 +0.835,0.181534,0.000303132,0.0862213 +0.84,0.183886,0.000315852,0.0874171 +0.845,0.186262,0.000328897,0.0886307 +0.85,0.188664,0.000342265,0.0898622 +0.855,0.191091,0.000355957,0.0911124 +0.86,0.193546,0.000369971,0.0923821 +0.865,0.196028,0.000384306,0.0936718 +0.87,0.198539,0.00039896,0.094982 +0.875,0.201077,0.00041393,0.0963125 +0.88,0.203644,0.000429213,0.0976638 +0.885,0.20624,0.000444804,0.0990366 +0.89,0.208865,0.000460698,0.100431 +0.895,0.211519,0.00047689,0.101847 +0.9,0.214203,0.000493372,0.103285 +0.905,0.216919,0.000510137,0.104747 +0.91,0.219666,0.000527178,0.106232 +0.915,0.222445,0.000544485,0.107742 +0.92,0.225258,0.000562049,0.109277 +0.925,0.228106,0.000579859,0.110838 +0.93,0.230989,0.000597905,0.112425 +0.935,0.233907,0.000616175,0.114038 +0.94,0.236861,0.000634655,0.115679 +0.945,0.239851,0.000653333,0.117347 +0.95,0.242878,0.000672193,0.119042 +0.955,0.245941,0.00069122,0.120765 +0.96,0.249042,0.000710398,0.122517 +0.965,0.25218,0.000729708,0.124297 +0.97,0.255357,0.000749133,0.126106 +0.975,0.258573,0.000768654,0.127946 +0.98,0.26183,0.000788252,0.129816 +0.985,0.265128,0.000807906,0.131718 +0.99,0.268468,0.000827596,0.133651 +0.995,0.271851,0.0008473,0.135616 +1,0.275276,0.000866996,0.137614 +1.005,0.278745,0.00088666,0.139644 +1.01,0.282256,0.00090627,0.141706 +1.015,0.285811,0.0009258,0.143802 +1.02,0.28941,0.000945225,0.14593 +1.025,0.293052,0.00096452,0.148092 +1.03,0.296738,0.000983658,0.150287 +1.035,0.30047,0.00100261,0.152517 +1.04,0.304248,0.00102135,0.154782 +1.045,0.308072,0.00103986,0.157081 +1.05,0.311943,0.00105809,0.159416 +1.055,0.315862,0.00107604,0.161787 +1.06,0.319828,0.00109365,0.164194 +1.065,0.323842,0.00111091,0.166636 +1.07,0.327904,0.00112779,0.169115 +1.075,0.332013,0.00114425,0.17163 +1.08,0.33617,0.00116026,0.174181 +1.085,0.340374,0.0011758,0.176768 +1.09,0.344626,0.00119082,0.179392 +1.095,0.348925,0.00120529,0.182052 +1.1,0.353274,0.00121918,0.18475 +1.105,0.357671,0.00123246,0.187484 +1.11,0.362116,0.00124509,0.190257 +1.115,0.366611,0.00125703,0.193067 +1.12,0.371156,0.00126824,0.195915 +1.125,0.375751,0.00127869,0.198802 +1.13,0.380394,0.00128834,0.201727 +1.135,0.385085,0.00129715,0.20469 +1.14,0.389826,0.00130508,0.207691 +1.145,0.394615,0.00131208,0.21073 +1.15,0.399452,0.0013181,0.213808 +1.155,0.404337,0.00132312,0.216924 +1.16,0.40927,0.00132708,0.220078 +1.165,0.414252,0.00132993,0.223272 +1.17,0.419282,0.00133162,0.226505 +1.175,0.424362,0.00133211,0.229777 +1.18,0.42949,0.00133136,0.23309 +1.185,0.434668,0.0013293,0.236442 +1.19,0.439894,0.00132588,0.239835 +1.195,0.445169,0.00132107,0.243267 +1.2,0.450492,0.0013148,0.24674 +1.205,0.455862,0.00130702,0.250252 +1.21,0.461281,0.00129769,0.253805 +1.215,0.466746,0.00128674,0.257398 +1.22,0.472259,0.00127413,0.261031 +1.225,0.47782,0.00125981,0.264705 +1.23,0.483429,0.00124372,0.26842 +1.235,0.489086,0.00122582,0.272176 +1.24,0.494791,0.00120607,0.275974 +1.245,0.500546,0.00118442,0.279814 +1.25,0.506348,0.00116082,0.283696 +1.255,0.512199,0.00113524,0.287619 +1.26,0.518097,0.00110764,0.291585 +1.265,0.524044,0.00107798,0.295592 +1.27,0.530038,0.00104624,0.299642 +1.275,0.536079,0.00101238,0.303733 +1.28,0.542168,0.000976389,0.307866 +1.285,0.548304,0.000938244,0.312042 +1.29,0.554487,0.00089793,0.316261 +1.295,0.560719,0.00085544,0.320522 +1.3,0.566999,0.000810768,0.324826 +1.305,0.573327,0.000763918,0.329174 +1.31,0.579704,0.000714896,0.333565 +1.315,0.586129,0.000663715,0.337999 +1.32,0.592602,0.000610395,0.342477 +1.325,0.599123,0.000554959,0.346999 +1.33,0.605691,0.000497439,0.351564 +1.335,0.612307,0.000437872,0.356172 +1.34,0.618969,0.000376302,0.360823 +1.345,0.625679,0.000312777,0.365518 +1.35,0.632436,0.000247356,0.370256 +1.355,0.63924,0.000180099,0.375038 +1.36,0.646091,0.000111078,0.379864 +1.365,0.65299,4.03674e-05,0.384734 +1.37,0.659936,-3.19502e-05,0.389648 +1.375,0.666931,-0.000105786,0.394606 +1.38,0.673972,-0.000181046,0.399608 +1.385,0.68106,-0.000257629,0.404655 +1.39,0.688195,-0.000335429,0.409745 +1.395,0.695376,-0.000414333,0.414878 +1.4,0.702602,-0.000494225,0.420056 +1.405,0.709874,-0.000574982,0.425276 +1.41,0.717192,-0.000656477,0.43054 +1.415,0.724555,-0.000738578,0.435848 +1.42,0.731963,-0.000821148,0.441199 +1.425,0.739417,-0.000904048,0.446594 +1.43,0.746917,-0.000987134,0.452033 +1.435,0.754461,-0.00107026,0.457515 +1.44,0.762051,-0.00115327,0.463041 +1.445,0.769686,-0.00123603,0.46861 +1.45,0.777365,-0.00131837,0.474222 +1.455,0.785087,-0.00140015,0.479877 +1.46,0.792853,-0.00148121,0.485575 +1.465,0.800662,-0.0015614,0.491315 +1.47,0.808514,-0.00164058,0.497098 +1.475,0.816408,-0.00171858,0.502922 +1.48,0.824344,-0.00179526,0.508789 +1.485,0.832323,-0.00187049,0.514698 +1.49,0.840344,-0.00194412,0.52065 +1.495,0.848406,-0.00201602,0.526643 +1.5,0.856511,-0.00208606,0.532678 +1.505,0.864657,-0.00215413,0.538755 +1.51,0.872845,-0.0022201,0.544873 +1.515,0.881072,-0.00228388,0.551032 +1.52,0.88934,-0.00234537,0.557232 +1.525,0.897647,-0.00240449,0.563472 +1.53,0.905993,-0.00246116,0.569753 +1.535,0.914377,-0.00251531,0.576073 +1.54,0.9228,-0.00256691,0.582433 +1.545,0.931261,-0.0026159,0.588833 +1.55,0.93976,-0.00266228,0.595273 +1.555,0.948297,-0.00270603,0.601751 +1.56,0.956872,-0.00274715,0.608269 +1.565,0.965483,-0.00278568,0.614826 +1.57,0.974132,-0.00282163,0.621421 +1.575,0.982817,-0.00285508,0.628055 +1.58,0.991538,-0.00288608,0.634727 +1.585,1.00029,-0.00291472,0.641436 +1.59,1.00908,-0.00294111,0.648182 +1.595,1.01791,-0.00296536,0.654965 +1.6,1.02677,-0.00298761,0.661785 +1.605,1.03566,-0.00300801,0.668641 +1.61,1.04458,-0.00302671,0.675532 +1.615,1.05354,-0.0030439,0.68246 +1.62,1.06253,-0.00305978,0.689423 +1.625,1.07155,-0.00307454,0.696422 +1.63,1.08061,-0.00308841,0.703456 +1.635,1.08969,-0.0031016,0.710524 +1.64,1.09881,-0.00311437,0.717626 +1.645,1.10795,-0.00312695,0.724763 +1.65,1.11713,-0.00313959,0.731932 +1.655,1.12633,-0.00315255,0.739135 +1.66,1.13557,-0.00316609,0.74637 +1.665,1.14483,-0.00318047,0.753636 +1.67,1.15412,-0.00319595,0.760935 +1.675,1.16343,-0.00321278,0.768265 +1.68,1.17278,-0.00323121,0.775627 +1.685,1.18214,-0.00325148,0.783019 +1.69,1.19154,-0.00327382,0.790443 +1.695,1.20096,-0.00329846,0.797896 +1.7,1.21041,-0.0033256,0.805379 +1.705,1.21988,-0.00335543,0.812892 +1.71,1.22938,-0.00338811,0.820433 +1.715,1.23889,-0.00342381,0.828003 +1.72,1.24844,-0.00346264,0.8356 +1.725,1.258,-0.00350471,0.843224 +1.73,1.26758,-0.00355008,0.850875 +1.735,1.27719,-0.00359882,0.858553 +1.74,1.28682,-0.00365093,0.866257 +1.745,1.29646,-0.0037064,0.873987 +1.75,1.30613,-0.00376518,0.881743 +1.755,1.31582,-0.0038272,0.889523 +1.76,1.32552,-0.00389235,0.897329 +1.765,1.33525,-0.00396048,0.905158 +1.77,1.34499,-0.00403142,0.913011 +1.775,1.35475,-0.00410496,0.920887 +1.78,1.36452,-0.00418086,0.928785 +1.785,1.37431,-0.00425886,0.936705 +1.79,1.38412,-0.00433866,0.944647 +1.795,1.39394,-0.00441993,0.952609 +1.8,1.40377,-0.00450235,0.960592 +1.805,1.41362,-0.00458553,0.968596 +1.81,1.42348,-0.00466911,0.976619 +1.815,1.43336,-0.00475268,0.984661 +1.82,1.44324,-0.00483585,0.992722 +1.825,1.45314,-0.0049182,1.0008 +1.83,1.46305,-0.00499932,1.0089 +1.835,1.47297,-0.00507881,1.01701 +1.84,1.4829,-0.00515628,1.02514 +1.845,1.49284,-0.00523132,1.03329 +1.85,1.50279,-0.00530358,1.04145 +1.855,1.51274,-0.00537272,1.04963 +1.86,1.5227,-0.00543841,1.05782 +1.865,1.53267,-0.00550038,1.06603 +1.87,1.54265,-0.00555837,1.07425 +1.875,1.55263,-0.00561218,1.08248 +1.88,1.56261,-0.00566166,1.09072 +1.885,1.5726,-0.00570668,1.09898 +1.89,1.5826,-0.0057472,1.10725 +1.895,1.5926,-0.00578321,1.11553 +1.9,1.6026,-0.00581475,1.12382 +1.905,1.6126,-0.00584194,1.13212 +1.91,1.6226,-0.00586494,1.14042 +1.915,1.63261,-0.00588399,1.14874 +1.92,1.64261,-0.00589936,1.15706 +1.925,1.65261,-0.0059114,1.1654 +1.93,1.66261,-0.00592049,1.17373 +1.935,1.67261,-0.00592707,1.18208 +1.94,1.68261,-0.00593163,1.19043 +1.945,1.69261,-0.0059347,1.19878 +1.95,1.7026,-0.00593682,1.20714 +1.955,1.71259,-0.00593859,1.21551 +1.96,1.72257,-0.00594061,1.22388 +1.965,1.73255,-0.00594349,1.23225 +1.97,1.74252,-0.00594786,1.24062 +1.975,1.75249,-0.00595433,1.249 +1.98,1.76244,-0.00596349,1.25737 +1.985,1.77239,-0.00597592,1.26575 +1.99,1.78233,-0.00599215,1.27412 +1.995,1.79226,-0.00601269,1.2825 +2,1.80219,-0.00603797,1.29087 +2.005,1.8121,-0.00606837,1.29925 +2.01,1.822,-0.00610421,1.30762 +2.015,1.83189,-0.00614573,1.31598 +2.02,1.84176,-0.00619306,1.32435 +2.025,1.85163,-0.00624627,1.33271 +2.03,1.86148,-0.00630534,1.34106 +2.035,1.87132,-0.00637012,1.34941 +2.04,1.88114,-0.00644041,1.35776 +2.045,1.89094,-0.00651587,1.36609 +2.05,1.90073,-0.00659608,1.37442 +2.055,1.9105,-0.00668054,1.38275 +2.06,1.92026,-0.00676863,1.39106 +2.065,1.92999,-0.00685969,1.39937 +2.07,1.93971,-0.00695296,1.40766 +2.075,1.94941,-0.00704762,1.41595 +2.08,1.95909,-0.00714281,1.42422 +2.085,1.96875,-0.00723762,1.43249 +2.09,1.97839,-0.00733113,1.44074 +2.095,1.98801,-0.0074224,1.44898 +2.1,1.9976,-0.0075105,1.45721 +2.105,2.00718,-0.00759454,1.46542 +2.11,2.01672,-0.00767365,1.47362 +2.115,2.02625,-0.00774704,1.4818 +2.12,2.03574,-0.00781398,1.48997 +2.125,2.04522,-0.00787383,1.49812 +2.13,2.05466,-0.00792608,1.50626 +2.135,2.06409,-0.00797032,1.51438 +2.14,2.07348,-0.00800627,1.52248 +2.145,2.08285,-0.00803382,1.53056 +2.15,2.09218,-0.00805299,1.53862 +2.155,2.10149,-0.00806395,1.54667 +2.16,2.11077,-0.00806705,1.55469 +2.165,2.12002,-0.00806279,1.5627 +2.17,2.12924,-0.00805183,1.57068 +2.175,2.13843,-0.00803496,1.57864 +2.18,2.14758,-0.00801314,1.58658 +2.185,2.1567,-0.00798743,1.59449 +2.19,2.16579,-0.00795902,1.60239 +2.195,2.17484,-0.00792916,1.61025 +2.2,2.18387,-0.00789921,1.6181 +2.205,2.19285,-0.00787054,1.62592 +2.21,2.2018,-0.00784455,1.63371 +2.215,2.21072,-0.00782263,1.64147 +2.22,2.2196,-0.00780613,1.64921 +2.225,2.22844,-0.00779633,1.65693 +2.23,2.23724,-0.00779441,1.66461 +2.235,2.24601,-0.00780144,1.67227 +2.24,2.25473,-0.00781829,1.67989 +2.245,2.26342,-0.00784571,1.68749 +2.25,2.27207,-0.0078842,1.69506 +2.255,2.28067,-0.00793406,1.70259 +2.26,2.28924,-0.00799534,1.7101 +2.265,2.29776,-0.00806785,1.71757 +2.27,2.30625,-0.00815115,1.72502 +2.275,2.31469,-0.00824452,1.73243 +2.28,2.32308,-0.00834701,1.7398 +2.285,2.33144,-0.00845742,1.74714 +2.29,2.33975,-0.00857433,1.75445 +2.295,2.34801,-0.00869612,1.76173 +2.3,2.35623,-0.00882099,1.76896 +2.305,2.36441,-0.008947,1.77617 +2.31,2.37254,-0.0090721,1.78333 +2.315,2.38062,-0.0091942,1.79046 +2.32,2.38865,-0.00931116,1.79755 +2.325,2.39664,-0.00942091,1.80461 +2.33,2.40458,-0.00952144,1.81163 +2.335,2.41247,-0.00961086,1.81861 +2.34,2.42032,-0.0096875,1.82555 +2.345,2.42811,-0.00974988,1.83245 +2.35,2.43586,-0.00979681,1.83931 +2.355,2.44355,-0.00982742,1.84613 +2.36,2.45119,-0.00984116,1.85291 +2.365,2.45879,-0.00983788,1.85964 +2.37,2.46633,-0.00981782,1.86634 +2.375,2.47381,-0.00978162,1.87299 +2.38,2.48125,-0.00973034,1.87961 +2.385,2.48864,-0.00966542,1.88617 +2.39,2.49597,-0.0095887,1.8927 +2.395,2.50325,-0.00950237,1.89918 +2.4,2.51047,-0.00940895,1.90562 +2.405,2.51764,-0.0093112,1.91201 +2.41,2.52476,-0.00921212,1.91836 +2.415,2.53182,-0.00911485,1.92467 +2.42,2.53883,-0.0090226,1.93093 +2.425,2.54578,-0.00893858,1.93714 +2.43,2.55267,-0.00886593,1.9433 +2.435,2.55951,-0.00880761,1.94942 +2.44,2.56629,-0.00876634,1.95549 +2.445,2.57301,-0.00874452,1.96152 +2.45,2.57968,-0.00874412,1.96749 +2.455,2.58629,-0.00876668,1.97342 +2.46,2.59284,-0.00881317,1.9793 +2.465,2.59934,-0.008884,1.98514 +2.47,2.60577,-0.00897894,1.99092 +2.475,2.61215,-0.00909715,1.99665 +2.48,2.61847,-0.00923711,2.00234 +2.485,2.62473,-0.00939668,2.00797 +2.49,2.63093,-0.0095731,2.01356 +2.495,2.63707,-0.00976305,2.01909 +2.5,2.64315,-0.0099627,2.02458 +2.505,2.64917,-0.0101678,2.03001 +2.51,2.65513,-0.0103737,2.03539 +2.515,2.66102,-0.0105757,2.04072 +2.52,2.66686,-0.0107687,2.046 +2.525,2.67264,-0.010948,2.05123 +2.53,2.67836,-0.0111087,2.0564 +2.535,2.68402,-0.0112464,2.06153 +2.54,2.68961,-0.0113569,2.0666 +2.545,2.69514,-0.0114369,2.07162 +2.55,2.70061,-0.0114834,2.07658 +2.555,2.70602,-0.0114945,2.0815 +2.56,2.71137,-0.0114689,2.08636 +2.565,2.71665,-0.0114065,2.09116 +2.57,2.72188,-0.0113079,2.09591 +2.575,2.72704,-0.0111749,2.10061 +2.58,2.73213,-0.0110105,2.10526 +2.585,2.73717,-0.0108182,2.10985 +2.59,2.74214,-0.010603,2.11439 +2.595,2.74705,-0.0103704,2.11887 +2.6,2.7519,-0.0101266,2.1233 +2.605,2.75668,-0.00987852,2.12768 +2.61,2.7614,-0.00963354,2.132 +2.615,2.76606,-0.00939916,2.13626 +2.62,2.77066,-0.00918296,2.14048 +2.625,2.77519,-0.00899236,2.14463 +2.63,2.77966,-0.00883435,2.14874 +2.635,2.78406,-0.00871532,2.15278 +2.64,2.78841,-0.00864083,2.15678 +2.645,2.79269,-0.00861543,2.16072 +2.65,2.79691,-0.00864246,2.1646 +2.655,2.80106,-0.00872389,2.16843 +2.66,2.80516,-0.00886022,2.17221 +2.665,2.80919,-0.0090504,2.17593 +2.67,2.81315,-0.00929176,2.17959 +2.675,2.81706,-0.00958002,2.18321 +2.68,2.8209,-0.00990934,2.18676 +2.685,2.82468,-0.0102724,2.19027 +2.69,2.8284,-0.0106606,2.19371 +2.695,2.83206,-0.0110642,2.19711 +2.7,2.83565,-0.0114724,2.20045 +2.705,2.83919,-0.0118739,2.20373 +2.71,2.84266,-0.0122572,2.20697 +2.715,2.84607,-0.0126104,2.21014 +2.72,2.84942,-0.0129223,2.21327 +2.725,2.85271,-0.0131821,2.21634 +2.73,2.85594,-0.0133803,2.21936 +2.735,2.85911,-0.0135084,2.22232 +2.74,2.86221,-0.01356,2.22523 +2.745,2.86526,-0.0135302,2.22809 +2.75,2.86825,-0.0134166,2.23089 +2.755,2.87118,-0.013219,2.23364 +2.76,2.87404,-0.0129399,2.23634 +2.765,2.87685,-0.012584,2.23899 +2.77,2.8796,-0.0121587,2.24158 +2.775,2.8823,-0.0116738,2.24412 +2.78,2.88493,-0.0111414,2.24662 +2.785,2.8875,-0.0105755,2.24905 +2.79,2.89002,-0.00999166,2.25144 +2.795,2.89248,-0.00940696,2.25378 +2.8,2.89488,-0.00883914,2.25606 +2.805,2.89723,-0.00830633,2.2583 +2.81,2.89952,-0.00782646,2.26048 +2.815,2.90175,-0.00741671,2.26262 +2.82,2.90393,-0.00709297,2.2647 +2.825,2.90605,-0.00686928,2.26674 +2.83,2.90812,-0.00675734,2.26873 +2.835,2.91014,-0.006766,2.27067 +2.84,2.9121,-0.0069009,2.27256 +2.845,2.914,-0.0071641,2.2744 +2.85,2.91586,-0.00755387,2.2762 +2.855,2.91766,-0.00806454,2.27795 +2.86,2.91941,-0.00868647,2.27965 +2.865,2.92111,-0.00940619,2.28131 +2.87,2.92276,-0.0102066,2.28292 +2.875,2.92436,-0.0110672,2.28449 +2.88,2.92591,-0.0119648,2.28601 +2.885,2.92741,-0.0128739,2.28748 +2.89,2.92886,-0.0137674,2.28892 +2.895,2.93027,-0.0146173,2.29031 +2.9,2.93163,-0.0153956,2.29165 +2.905,2.93294,-0.0160752,2.29296 +2.91,2.93421,-0.0166306,2.29422 +2.915,2.93543,-0.0170389,2.29544 +2.92,2.9366,-0.0172806,2.29663 +2.925,2.93773,-0.0173402,2.29776 +2.93,2.93882,-0.0172074,2.29886 +2.935,2.93986,-0.016877,2.29992 +2.94,2.94086,-0.0163497,2.30094 +2.945,2.94181,-0.0156322,2.30192 +2.95,2.94273,-0.0147376,2.30287 +2.955,2.9436,-0.0136849,2.30377 +2.96,2.94444,-0.0124989,2.30464 +2.965,2.94523,-0.0112099,2.30547 +2.97,2.94599,-0.00985261,2.30627 +2.975,2.9467,-0.00846573,2.30703 +2.98,2.94738,-0.00709069,2.30775 +2.985,2.94803,-0.0057706,2.30844 +2.99,2.94863,-0.00454898,2.3091 +2.995,2.94921,-0.00346846,2.30973 +3,2.94974,-0.00256937,2.31033 +3.005,2.95025,-0.00188843,2.31089 +3.01,2.95072,-0.00145741,2.31142 +3.015,2.95116,-0.0013019,2.31193 +3.02,2.95157,-0.00144024,2.3124 +3.025,2.95195,-0.00188253,2.31285 +3.03,2.9523,-0.00262999,2.31327 +3.035,2.95262,-0.00367443,2.31366 +3.04,2.95291,-0.00499804,2.31403 +3.045,2.95318,-0.00657348,2.31437 +3.05,2.95343,-0.00836427,2.31469 +3.055,2.95365,-0.0103254,2.31498 +3.06,2.95385,-0.0124044,2.31525 +3.065,2.95403,-0.0145426,2.3155 +3.07,2.95418,-0.0166764,2.31573 +3.075,2.95432,-0.0187393,2.31595 +3.08,2.95444,-0.0206637,2.31614 +3.085,2.95454,-0.0223831,2.31631 +3.09,2.95463,-0.0238337,2.31647 +3.095,2.9547,-0.0249572,2.31661 +3.1,2.95475,-0.0257025,2.31674 +3.105,2.95479,-0.0260276,2.31685 +3.11,2.95482,-0.0259016,2.31694 +3.115,2.95483,-0.0253059,2.31702 +3.12,2.95483,-0.0242359,2.31709 +3.125,2.95482,-0.022701,2.31714 +3.13,2.9548,-0.0207261,2.31718 +3.135,2.95476,-0.0183505,2.3172 +3.14,2.95472,-0.0156282,2.31722 +3.145,2.95468,-0.0126266,2.31723 +3.15,2.95462,-0.00942511,2.31723 +3.155,2.95456,-0.00611334,2.31722 +3.16,2.9545,-0.0027888,2.31721 +3.165,2.95444,0.000445771,2.3172 +3.17,2.95438,0.00348526,2.31718 +3.175,2.95431,0.0062254,2.31716 +3.18,2.95425,0.00856601,2.31714 +3.185,2.95419,0.0104143,2.31712 +3.19,2.95414,0.0116883,2.31711 +3.195,2.95409,0.0123195,2.31709 +3.2,2.95404,0.0122563,2.31708 +3.205,2.954,0.011466,2.31707 +3.21,2.95397,0.00993673,2.31705 +3.215,2.95393,0.00767924,2.31704 +3.22,2.95389,0.00472739,2.31702 +3.225,2.95386,0.00113838,2.31701 +3.23,2.95383,-0.00300787,2.31699 +3.235,2.9538,-0.00761007,2.31698 +3.24,2.95377,-0.0125476,2.31696 +3.245,2.95375,-0.0176833,2.31695 +3.25,2.95374,-0.022867,2.31695 +3.255,2.95374,-0.0279392,2.31695 +3.26,2.95375,-0.0327362,2.31696 +3.265,2.95376,-0.0370944,2.31698 +3.27,2.95379,-0.0408556,2.317 +3.275,2.95382,-0.0438723,2.31703 +3.28,2.95386,-0.0460128,2.31707 +3.285,2.9539,-0.0471661,2.3171 +3.29,2.95394,-0.0472465,2.31714 +3.295,2.95399,-0.0461976,2.31717 +3.3,2.95403,-0.043995,2.3172 +3.305,2.95407,-0.0406498,2.31722 +3.31,2.95411,-0.0362088,2.31724 +3.315,2.95414,-0.030756,2.31725 +3.32,2.95418,-0.0244109,2.31726 +3.325,2.95422,-0.0173274,2.31727 +3.33,2.95426,-0.00969002,2.31727 +3.335,2.95431,-0.00171034,2.31728 +3.34,2.95437,0.0063787,2.3173 +3.345,2.95443,0.0143288,2.31733 +3.35,2.9545,0.0218833,2.31737 +3.355,2.95459,0.0287849,2.31741 +3.36,2.95467,0.0347837,2.31747 +3.365,2.95476,0.0396453,2.31754 +3.37,2.95486,0.0431592,2.31761 +3.375,2.95496,0.0451466,2.31769 +3.38,2.95505,0.0454674,2.31777 +3.385,2.95515,0.044027,2.31784 +3.39,2.95525,0.0407815,2.3179 +3.395,2.95535,0.0357415,2.31796 +3.4,2.95545,0.0289749,2.31802 +3.405,2.95556,0.0206076,2.31806 +3.41,2.95568,0.0108225,2.31811 +3.415,2.95582,-0.000143049,2.31815 +3.42,2.95598,-0.0120021,2.31821 +3.425,2.95615,-0.0244244,2.31828 +3.43,2.95636,-0.0370447,2.31837 +3.435,2.95659,-0.0494724,2.31849 +3.44,2.95686,-0.0613025,2.31864 +3.445,2.95716,-0.0721281,2.31882 +3.45,2.95748,-0.0815534,2.31904 +3.455,2.95783,-0.0892064,2.31928 +3.46,2.9582,-0.0947527,2.31953 +3.465,2.95858,-0.0979081,2.3198 +3.47,2.95895,-0.0984503,2.32006 +3.475,2.95933,-0.0962294,2.32031 +3.48,2.9597,-0.0911767,2.32054 +3.485,2.96005,-0.083311,2.32074 +3.49,2.96039,-0.0727428,2.3209 +3.495,2.96073,-0.0596756,2.32103 +3.5,2.96106,-0.0444046,2.32114 +3.505,2.96141,-0.0273118,2.32124 +3.51,2.96177,-0.00885865,2.32134 +3.515,2.96216,0.0104248,2.32146 +3.52,2.96259,0.0299534,2.32162 +3.525,2.96306,0.0491028,2.32183 +3.53,2.96358,0.0672282,2.32209 +3.535,2.96415,0.0836845,2.32242 +3.54,2.96476,0.0978479,2.32282 +3.545,2.9654,0.109138,2.32326 +3.55,2.96605,0.117038,2.32374 +3.555,2.96671,0.121119,2.32422 +3.56,2.96737,0.121054,2.3247 +3.565,2.96801,0.11664,2.32515 +3.57,2.96863,0.107807,2.32554 +3.575,2.96922,0.0946273,2.32587 +3.58,2.96981,0.0773251,2.32614 +3.585,2.97039,0.056273,2.32636 +3.59,2.97099,0.0319899,2.32653 +3.595,2.97163,0.00513109,2.3267 +3.6,2.97234,-0.0235261,2.3269 +3.605,2.97312,-0.0531023,2.32716 +3.61,2.97401,-0.0826403,2.32752 +3.615,2.97501,-0.111135,2.328 +3.62,2.97611,-0.137566,2.32862 +3.625,2.97732,-0.160931,2.32939 +3.63,2.97861,-0.180288,2.33027 +3.635,2.97995,-0.194785,2.33125 +3.64,2.98131,-0.203702,2.33227 +3.645,2.98265,-0.206475,2.33328 +3.65,2.98395,-0.202731,2.33422 +3.655,2.98516,-0.192307,2.33505 +3.66,2.98628,-0.175263,2.33571 +3.665,2.9873,-0.151896,2.33619 +3.67,2.98822,-0.122737,2.33649 +3.675,2.98909,-0.0885455,2.33665 +3.68,2.98993,-0.0502973,2.3367 +3.685,2.99079,-0.00915668,2.33673 +3.69,2.99173,0.0335528,2.33681 +3.695,2.99279,0.0763894,2.33703 +3.7,2.99402,0.11784,2.33746 +3.705,2.99541,0.156373,2.33815 +3.71,2.99699,0.190496,2.33911 +3.715,2.99871,0.218812,2.34034 +3.72,3.00054,0.240077,2.34177 +3.725,3.00241,0.253255,2.34332 +3.73,3.00426,0.257559,2.34488 +3.735,3.00601,0.252496,2.34633 +3.74,3.0076,0.237893,2.34757 +3.745,3.00899,0.213916,2.3485 +3.75,3.01017,0.181076,2.34908 +3.755,3.01116,0.14023,2.34931 +3.76,3.01201,0.0925586,2.34925 +3.765,3.0128,0.03954,2.34899 +3.77,3.01363,-0.0170929,2.34868 +3.775,3.01461,-0.0754069,2.34848 +3.78,3.01581,-0.133333,2.34855 +3.785,3.01733,-0.188742,2.34902 +3.79,3.01918,-0.239524,2.34997 +3.795,3.02136,-0.28367,2.35143 +3.8,3.02382,-0.319355,2.35335 +3.805,3.02644,-0.345014,2.3556 +3.81,3.02911,-0.359406,2.358 +3.815,3.03167,-0.361671,2.36035 +3.82,3.03398,-0.351374,2.36242 +3.825,3.03591,-0.328523,2.36402 +3.83,3.03739,-0.293591,2.36499 +3.835,3.0384,-0.247504,2.36529 +3.84,3.03899,-0.191626,2.36494 +3.845,3.03927,-0.127722,2.36406 +3.85,3.03942,-0.0579101,2.36287 +3.855,3.03963,0.0154049,2.36165 +3.86,3.04011,0.089611,2.36069 +3.865,3.04103,0.161981,2.36027 +3.87,3.0425,0.229777,2.36059 +3.875,3.04457,0.290352,2.36176 +3.88,3.04719,0.341266,2.36378 +3.885,3.05023,0.380382,2.36651 +3.89,3.05347,0.40596,2.36969 +3.895,3.05668,0.416735,2.37299 +3.9,3.05959,0.411972,2.37605 +3.905,3.06197,0.391502,2.37851 +3.91,3.06365,0.355738,2.3801 +3.915,3.06456,0.305667,2.38065 +3.92,3.06475,0.242824,2.38016 +3.925,3.06437,0.169249,2.37877 +3.93,3.06368,0.087421,2.37675 +3.935,3.06299,0.000183888,2.37452 +3.94,3.06262,-0.0893514,2.3725 +3.945,3.0629,-0.177914,2.37116 +3.95,3.06404,-0.262194,2.37086 +3.955,3.06613,-0.338967,2.37179 +3.96,3.0691,-0.405227,2.37399 +3.965,3.07275,-0.458305,2.3773 +3.97,3.07678,-0.495985,2.38137 +3.975,3.08081,-0.516594,2.38574 +3.98,3.08447,-0.519072,2.3899 +3.985,3.08741,-0.503018,2.39334 +3.99,3.08937,-0.468708,2.39562 +3.995,3.09021,-0.417087,2.39646 +4,3.08996,-0.349743,2.39579 +4.005,3.08878,-0.26886,2.39373 +4.01,3.08702,-0.177155,2.39062 +4.015,3.08508,-0.0777946,2.38697 +4.02,3.08343,0.0256997,2.38339 +4.025,3.08252,0.129571,2.38049 +4.03,3.08273,0.229959,2.37886 +4.035,3.08428,0.323049,2.3789 +4.04,3.08718,0.405226,2.38076 +4.045,3.09122,0.473228,2.38431 +4.05,3.09602,0.524287,2.38919 +4.055,3.10109,0.55625,2.39479 +4.06,3.10584,0.567671,2.40041 +4.065,3.10971,0.557868,2.40528 +4.07,3.11225,0.526946,2.40875 +4.075,3.11322,0.47579,2.41037 +4.08,3.11259,0.406027,2.40995 +4.085,3.11059,0.319965,2.40759 +4.09,3.10765,0.22052,2.40368 +4.095,3.10437,0.111128,2.39887 +4.1,3.10141,-0.00436869,2.39394 +4.105,3.09934,-0.121835,2.38969 +4.11,3.09866,-0.236987,2.38685 +4.115,3.09966,-0.345547,2.386 +4.12,3.1024,-0.443408,2.3874 +4.125,3.10668,-0.526802,2.39101 +4.13,3.11206,-0.59246,2.39642 +4.135,3.11796,-0.63775,2.403 +4.14,3.1237,-0.660785,2.40989 +4.145,3.12859,-0.660496,2.41618 +4.15,3.13201,-0.636667,2.42099 +4.155,3.13358,-0.589932,2.42367 +4.16,3.13316,-0.521749,2.42387 +4.165,3.13091,-0.434341,2.42156 +4.17,3.12724,-0.330625,2.41708 +4.175,3.1228,-0.214133,2.4111 +4.18,3.11839,-0.0889071,2.4045 +4.185,3.11479,0.0406173,2.39831 +4.19,3.11267,0.169753,2.39349 +4.195,3.1125,0.293728,2.39086 +4.2,3.1145,0.40787,2.39092 +4.205,3.11857,0.507806,2.39382 +4.21,3.1243,0.58965,2.39925 +4.215,3.131,0.650182,2.40654 +4.22,3.13786,0.686983,2.41472 +4.225,3.14403,0.698537,2.42267 +4.23,3.14868,0.684276,2.4293 +4.235,3.15119,0.644582,2.43366 +4.24,3.15128,0.580755,2.43517 +4.245,3.14902,0.494941,2.43365 +4.25,3.14482,0.390054,2.42936 +4.255,3.13939,0.269677,2.42293 +4.26,3.13363,0.137962,2.41534 +4.265,3.12852,-0.000492537,2.40775 +4.27,3.12495,-0.140776,2.40134 +4.275,3.12353,-0.277829,2.39712 +4.28,3.12462,-0.406622,2.39582 +4.285,3.12822,-0.522356,2.39778 +4.29,3.13398,-0.620662,2.40285 +4.295,3.14121,-0.697788,2.41041 +4.3,3.14899,-0.750759,2.41945 +4.305,3.15633,-0.777499,2.42874 +4.31,3.16227,-0.776909,2.43701 +4.315,3.16601,-0.748884,2.44308 +4.32,3.16705,-0.694302,2.44611 +4.325,3.16529,-0.614967,2.44568 +4.33,3.16106,-0.513535,2.44186 +4.335,3.15504,-0.393425,2.4352 +4.34,3.14818,-0.258725,2.42664 +4.345,3.14157,-0.114087,2.4174 +4.35,3.13628,0.0354071,2.40885 +4.355,3.13319,0.184396,2.40225 +4.36,3.13283,0.32743,2.39864 +4.365,3.13536,0.459179,2.39862 +4.37,3.14056,0.574668,2.40231 +4.375,3.14783,0.669491,2.40928 +4.38,3.15621,0.740021,2.41859 +4.385,3.1646,0.783564,2.42895 +4.39,3.1719,0.798467,2.4389 +4.395,3.17714,0.784162,2.44707 +4.4,3.17962,0.741153,2.45233 +4.405,3.17903,0.670957,2.45396 +4.41,3.17554,0.576018,2.45181 +4.415,3.16972,0.459603,2.44622 +4.42,3.16249,0.325696,2.43802 +4.425,3.15493,0.178891,2.42837 +4.43,3.1482,0.0242682,2.41867 +4.435,3.14335,-0.132744,2.41036 +4.44,3.14113,-0.286544,2.40469 +4.445,3.14194,-0.431553,2.40256 +4.45,3.14576,-0.562435,2.4044 +4.455,3.15219,-0.674323,2.41007 +4.46,3.16045,-0.76303,2.41886 +4.465,3.16945,-0.825233,2.42957 +4.47,3.178,-0.858605,2.44071 +4.475,3.18495,-0.861901,2.45072 +4.48,3.18934,-0.834978,2.45821 +4.485,3.19057,-0.778763,2.46211 +4.49,3.18845,-0.695187,2.4619 +4.495,3.18333,-0.587094,2.45761 +4.5,3.17599,-0.458148,2.44984 +4.505,3.16752,-0.312729,2.43964 +4.51,3.15919,-0.155828,2.42844 +4.515,3.15224,0.00708194,2.41781 +4.52,3.14775,0.170208,2.4093 +4.525,3.14644,0.327636,2.40417 +4.53,3.14858,0.473556,2.40325 +4.535,3.15396,0.602518,2.40675 +4.54,3.16193,0.70967,2.41428 +4.545,3.17144,0.790989,2.42478 +4.55,3.18119,0.843456,2.43676 +4.555,3.18982,0.865175,2.44851 +4.56,3.19615,0.855422,2.45836 +4.565,3.19931,0.814634,2.46495 +4.57,3.19886,0.744338,2.4674 +4.575,3.19492,0.647047,2.46541 +4.58,3.18812,0.526151,2.45933 +4.585,3.17949,0.385803,2.45005 +4.59,3.1703,0.230804,2.43889 +4.595,3.16191,0.0664854,2.42741 +4.6,3.15553,-0.101435,2.41727 +4.605,3.15214,-0.267022,2.40996 +4.61,3.15226,-0.424331,2.40661 +4.615,3.15593,-0.567632,2.40778 +4.62,3.16271,-0.691654,2.4134 +4.625,3.17173,-0.791813,2.42276 +4.63,3.1818,-0.864413,2.43456 +4.635,3.19151,-0.906801,2.44712 +4.64,3.19951,-0.917468,2.45865 +4.645,3.20469,-0.896074,2.46753 +4.65,3.20632,-0.843425,2.47253 +4.655,3.20418,-0.761392,2.47298 +4.66,3.1986,-0.652816,2.46883 +4.665,3.19041,-0.521401,2.46068 +4.67,3.18083,-0.371612,2.44963 +4.675,3.17124,-0.208564,2.43719 +4.68,3.16302,-0.037901,2.42508 +4.685,3.15738,0.134361,2.41498 +4.69,3.15516,0.302031,2.40837 +4.695,3.1567,0.458975,2.40625 +4.7,3.16186,0.599372,2.40899 +4.705,3.16995,0.717984,2.41626 +4.71,3.17991,0.810391,2.42704 +4.715,3.19036,0.8732,2.4398 +4.72,3.19986,0.904182,2.45269 +4.725,3.20707,0.902336,2.46388 +4.73,3.211,0.867883,2.4718 +4.735,3.21113,0.802197,2.47542 +4.74,3.20748,0.707694,2.4743 +4.745,3.2006,0.587714,2.46864 +4.75,3.19151,0.446397,2.45928 +4.755,3.18152,0.288571,2.44754 +4.76,3.17206,0.119638,2.43503 +4.765,3.16445,-0.0545647,2.4235 +4.77,3.15979,-0.22793,2.41462 +4.775,3.15876,-0.394282,2.40971 +4.78,3.16157,-0.547608,2.40955 +4.785,3.16787,-0.682307,2.41427 +4.79,3.17684,-0.793434,2.42326 +4.795,3.1873,-0.876917,2.43529 +4.8,3.1978,-0.929736,2.44865 +4.805,3.20685,-0.950037,2.4614 +4.81,3.21317,-0.937178,2.47175 +4.815,3.21585,-0.891711,2.47824 +4.82,3.21451,-0.815306,2.48 +4.825,3.20934,-0.710654,2.47682 +4.83,3.2011,-0.581352,2.46913 +4.835,3.19098,-0.431799,2.45798 +4.84,3.18044,-0.267087,2.44489 +4.845,3.17098,-0.0928826,2.43164 +4.85,3.16396,0.0847192,2.42005 +4.855,3.1604,0.259385,2.41178 +4.86,3.16082,0.424773,2.40805 +4.865,3.16522,0.574789,2.40947 +4.87,3.173,0.703864,2.41586 +4.875,3.18311,0.807206,2.42634 +4.88,3.19413,0.881029,2.4394 +4.885,3.20453,0.92271,2.45313 +4.89,3.21282,0.930883,2.46555 +4.895,3.21784,0.905445,2.47492 +4.9,3.21892,0.847498,2.47997 +4.905,3.21593,0.759243,2.48008 +4.91,3.20934,0.643849,2.47533 +4.915,3.20013,0.505333,2.46641 +4.92,3.18962,0.348435,2.45459 +4.925,3.17931,0.178511,2.4415 +4.93,3.17063,0.00139805,2.42895 +4.935,3.16479,-0.176739,2.4187 +4.94,3.16262,-0.349602,2.41224 +4.945,3.16443,-0.510984,2.41058 +4.95,3.17002,-0.655022,2.41402 +4.955,3.17863,-0.776448,2.42215 +4.96,3.18911,-0.870823,2.43383 +4.965,3.20001,-0.934734,2.44742 +4.97,3.20982,-0.965935,2.46096 +4.975,3.21712,-0.963411,2.47252 +4.98,3.22089,-0.927379,2.48047 +4.985,3.22058,-0.859219,2.48374 +4.99,3.21626,-0.761379,2.48192 +4.995,3.20853,-0.637254,2.47529 +5,3.19851,-0.491079,2.46472 +5.005,3.18761,-0.32782,2.45165 +5.01,3.17737,-0.153066,2.43783 +5.015,3.16924,0.0271137,2.42514 +5.02,3.16436,0.206342,2.41536 +5.025,3.16342,0.378153,2.40989 +5.03,3.16661,0.536253,2.40959 +5.035,3.17349,0.67479,2.41454 +5.04,3.18314,0.78863,2.42406 +5.045,3.19422,0.873593,2.43678 +5.05,3.20517,0.926643,2.45085 +5.055,3.21446,0.945999,2.46423 +5.06,3.22076,0.931172,2.47501 +5.065,3.22318,0.882916,2.48172 +5.07,3.22142,0.803131,2.48349 +5.075,3.21575,0.694739,2.48017 +5.08,3.20701,0.561548,2.47227 +5.085,3.19644,0.408138,2.46091 +5.09,3.18554,0.239739,2.44766 +5.095,3.17584,0.0621125,2.43434 +5.1,3.16868,-0.118593,2.42281 +5.105,3.16506,-0.296029,2.41472 +5.11,3.1655,-0.463865,2.41128 +5.115,3.16997,-0.616034,2.41307 +5.12,3.17788,-0.746988,2.41991 +5.125,3.18815,-0.851946,2.43086 +5.13,3.19937,-0.927107,2.44436 +5.135,3.20995,-0.969808,2.45846 +5.14,3.2184,-0.978623,2.47115 +5.145,3.22348,-0.953374,2.48061 +5.15,3.22447,-0.895091,2.48555 +5.155,3.22124,-0.805911,2.48534 +5.16,3.21425,-0.688967,2.48004 +5.165,3.20451,-0.548272,2.47037 +5.17,3.1934,-0.388607,2.45764 +5.175,3.18249,-0.215417,2.44354 +5.18,3.17331,-0.0346787,2.43 +5.185,3.16716,0.147256,2.41888 +5.19,3.16488,0.323873,2.41176 +5.195,3.16681,0.488738,2.40968 +5.2,3.17271,0.635771,2.41301 +5.205,3.18176,0.759527,2.42129 +5.21,3.19271,0.855448,2.43334 +5.215,3.204,0.920074,2.44738 +5.22,3.21406,0.951186,2.46137 +5.225,3.22146,0.947865,2.47332 +5.23,3.22516,0.91047,2.48156 +5.235,3.22467,0.840553,2.48502 +5.24,3.22008,0.740732,2.4833 +5.245,3.21209,0.614563,2.47673 +5.25,3.20184,0.466409,2.46624 +5.255,3.19077,0.301326,2.45328 +5.26,3.18042,0.124946,2.43962 +5.265,3.17222,-0.0566591,2.42716 +5.27,3.1673,-0.237148,2.41764 +5.275,3.16633,-0.410119,2.41246 +5.28,3.16947,-0.569348,2.41243 +5.285,3.17632,-0.709046,2.41765 +5.29,3.18596,-0.824116,2.42741 +5.295,3.19706,-0.910379,2.44034 +5.3,3.20807,-0.964759,2.45458 +5.305,3.21743,-0.985396,2.46808 +5.31,3.22382,-0.971695,2.47893 +5.315,3.22629,-0.924292,2.4856 +5.32,3.22448,-0.844975,2.48722 +5.325,3.21867,-0.736567,2.4836 +5.33,3.20968,-0.602815,2.47524 +5.335,3.19876,-0.448271,2.46327 +5.34,3.18747,-0.278193,2.44928 +5.345,3.17738,-0.0984189,2.43516 +5.35,3.16992,0.0847757,2.42283 +5.355,3.16612,0.264875,2.41404 +5.36,3.16653,0.435356,2.41006 +5.365,3.17111,0.589959,2.41152 +5.37,3.17925,0.722964,2.41824 +5.375,3.18981,0.829462,2.42927 +5.38,3.2013,0.905582,2.44299 +5.385,3.21211,0.948659,2.4574 +5.39,3.22068,0.957323,2.47041 +5.395,3.22582,0.931503,2.48019 +5.4,3.2268,0.872361,2.48542 +5.405,3.22351,0.782175,2.48547 +5.41,3.21645,0.66421,2.48041 +5.415,3.20666,0.522579,2.47101 +5.42,3.19552,0.362132,2.45856 +5.425,3.18458,0.188335,2.44477 +5.43,3.17537,0.00714794,2.43155 +5.435,3.16916,-0.175141,2.42074 +5.44,3.16678,-0.352103,2.4139 +5.445,3.16858,-0.517405,2.41205 +5.45,3.17433,-0.665058,2.41555 +5.455,3.18326,-0.789681,2.42395 +5.46,3.19413,-0.886738,2.43609 +5.465,3.20543,-0.95274,2.4502 +5.47,3.21556,-0.985391,2.46426 +5.475,3.22308,-0.983655,2.47626 +5.48,3.22691,-0.947751,2.48452 +5.485,3.2265,-0.879088,2.48792 +5.49,3.22191,-0.780154,2.48603 +5.495,3.2138,-0.654398,2.47915 +5.5,3.20332,-0.506118,2.46821 +5.505,3.19194,-0.340352,2.45467 +5.51,3.18125,-0.162765,2.44032 +5.515,3.17275,0.0204855,2.42712 +5.52,3.16761,0.202928,2.4169 +5.525,3.16656,0.377995,2.41113 +5.53,3.16974,0.539286,2.41066 +5.535,3.17674,0.680846,2.41561 +5.54,3.1866,0.797439,2.4253 +5.545,3.19793,0.8848,2.43832 +5.55,3.20913,0.939823,2.45275 +5.555,3.21863,0.960678,2.4665 +5.56,3.22507,0.946847,2.47762 +5.565,3.22756,0.899078,2.48459 +5.57,3.22576,0.81928,2.4865 +5.575,3.21995,0.710396,2.4832 +5.58,3.21099,0.576263,2.47519 +5.585,3.20014,0.421496,2.46361 +5.59,3.18893,0.251369,2.45004 +5.595,3.1789,0.0716948,2.43634 +5.6,3.17144,-0.111321,2.42442 +5.605,3.16758,-0.291261,2.41596 +5.61,3.16784,-0.461718,2.41222 +5.615,3.17222,-0.616541,2.41382 +5.62,3.18014,-0.750097,2.4206 +5.625,3.19051,-0.85752,2.43163 +5.63,3.2019,-0.934928,2.44533 +5.635,3.2127,-0.979591,2.45972 +5.64,3.22137,-0.990026,2.47274 +5.645,3.22665,-0.966017,2.48254 +5.65,3.2278,-0.908567,2.48777 +5.655,3.22463,-0.819803,2.48775 +5.66,3.2176,-0.702855,2.48253 +5.665,3.20771,-0.561742,2.47281 +5.67,3.19637,-0.401262,2.45991 +5.675,3.18515,-0.226883,2.44554 +5.68,3.17564,-0.0446154,2.43164 +5.685,3.16916,0.139147,2.42012 +5.69,3.16661,0.317834,2.41262 +5.695,3.16835,0.484948,2.41023 +5.7,3.17416,0.634335,2.41335 +5.705,3.18322,0.76047,2.42156 +5.71,3.19429,0.858714,2.43366 +5.715,3.20579,0.925529,2.4479 +5.72,3.21609,0.958626,2.46217 +5.725,3.22373,0.957024,2.47443 +5.73,3.22764,0.921035,2.48299 +5.735,3.22728,0.852178,2.48671 +5.74,3.22273,0.75305,2.48518 +5.745,3.21468,0.627195,2.47868 +5.75,3.20429,0.478971,2.46816 +5.755,3.193,0.31344,2.45506 +5.76,3.1824,0.136243,2.44118 +5.765,3.17392,-0.0465273,2.42842 +5.77,3.16874,-0.2285,2.41857 +5.775,3.16757,-0.403232,2.41308 +5.78,3.17057,-0.564444,2.41279 +5.785,3.17735,-0.706284,2.41781 +5.79,3.18699,-0.823583,2.42749 +5.795,3.19817,-0.912083,2.44046 +5.8,3.20932,-0.96863,2.45484 +5.805,3.21886,-0.991294,2.46856 +5.81,3.22543,-0.979413,2.47967 +5.815,3.22807,-0.933572,2.48664 +5.82,3.22642,-0.855515,2.48852 +5.825,3.22069,-0.748034,2.4851 +5.83,3.2117,-0.61485,2.47687 +5.835,3.20073,-0.460501,2.46493 +5.84,3.1893,-0.290234,2.45086 +5.845,3.17902,-0.109888,2.43656 +5.85,3.17132,0.0742529,2.42396 +5.855,3.16726,0.255648,2.41485 +5.86,3.16743,0.427737,2.41053 +5.865,3.17181,0.584207,2.41167 +5.87,3.17981,0.719275,2.41815 +5.875,3.19032,0.827958,2.42905 +5.88,3.20186,0.906304,2.44277 +5.885,3.21281,0.951571,2.45731 +5.89,3.22159,0.962311,2.47054 +5.895,3.22696,0.938387,2.48062 +5.9,3.22818,0.880903,2.48618 +5.905,3.2251,0.792092,2.48653 +5.91,3.21819,0.675179,2.48172 +5.915,3.20843,0.53425,2.47246 +5.92,3.19723,0.374134,2.46004 +5.925,3.18614,0.200284,2.44617 +5.93,3.17669,0.0186556,2.43274 +5.935,3.17019,-0.164455,2.42164 +5.94,3.16752,-0.342599,2.41445 +5.945,3.16906,-0.509408,2.41225 +5.95,3.17461,-0.658846,2.41545 +5.955,3.18342,-0.785472,2.42364 +5.96,3.19429,-0.884676,2.43567 +5.965,3.20569,-0.952895,2.44983 +5.97,3.21602,-0.987752,2.46405 +5.975,3.22378,-0.988134,2.47631 +5.98,3.22787,-0.954191,2.48488 +5.985,3.2277,-0.887269,2.48861 +5.99,3.2233,-0.789804,2.48702 +5.995,3.21528,-0.665204,2.48036 +6,3.2048,-0.517731,2.46954 +6.005,3.19332,-0.352395,2.456 +6.01,3.18246,-0.174844,2.44155 +6.015,3.17372,0.0087747,2.42813 +6.02,3.16831,0.191986,2.41762 +6.025,3.167,0.368204,2.41151 +6.03,3.16996,0.530995,2.4107 +6.035,3.17681,0.674351,2.41537 +6.04,3.18658,0.792973,2.42486 +6.045,3.19793,0.882518,2.43779 +6.05,3.20924,0.939797,2.45227 +6.055,3.21891,0.962898,2.46618 +6.06,3.22557,0.951222,2.47755 +6.065,3.22828,0.905445,2.48481 +6.07,3.2267,0.827415,2.48704 +6.075,3.22106,0.720024,2.48402 +6.08,3.2122,0.587066,2.47623 +6.085,3.20137,0.43312,2.46478 +6.09,3.1901,0.263433,2.45123 +6.095,3.17993,0.0837991,2.43743 +6.1,3.17226,-0.0995851,2.4253 +6.105,3.16814,-0.280297,2.41655 +6.11,3.16815,-0.451911,2.41248 +6.115,3.1723,-0.608238,2.41374 +6.12,3.18003,-0.743595,2.42022 +6.125,3.1903,-0.853051,2.43105 +6.13,3.20168,-0.932647,2.44467 +6.135,3.21257,-0.979575,2.45912 +6.14,3.22142,-0.992268,2.47231 +6.145,3.22695,-0.970432,2.48239 +6.15,3.22837,-0.914999,2.48795 +6.155,3.22546,-0.82803,2.48829 +6.16,3.21865,-0.712603,2.48337 +6.165,3.20889,-0.572689,2.47389 +6.17,3.19756,-0.413046,2.46111 +6.175,3.18626,-0.23911,2.44673 +6.18,3.17656,-0.0568706,2.43269 +6.185,3.16981,0.127288,2.42092 +6.19,3.16695,0.306791,2.41308 +6.195,3.16839,0.475116,2.41032 +6.2,3.17395,0.626072,2.41308 +6.205,3.18285,0.754076,2.42099 +6.21,3.19385,0.854418,2.43292 +6.215,3.20541,0.92348,2.44712 +6.22,3.21588,0.958887,2.4615 +6.225,3.22376,0.959572,2.474 +6.23,3.22796,0.925768,2.48287 +6.235,3.22788,0.858919,2.48694 +6.24,3.22358,0.761562,2.48575 +6.245,3.2157,0.637187,2.47953 +6.25,3.20537,0.490109,2.46919 +6.255,3.19403,0.325352,2.45616 +6.26,3.18328,0.148531,2.44222 +6.265,3.17459,-0.034282,2.42929 +6.27,3.16915,-0.21672,2.41917 +6.275,3.16769,-0.392331,2.41335 +6.28,3.17044,-0.554812,2.4127 +6.285,3.17703,-0.698269,2.41741 +6.29,3.18656,-0.817474,2.42685 +6.295,3.19772,-0.908099,2.43969 +6.3,3.20895,-0.96691,2.45407 +6.305,3.21866,-0.991891,2.46793 +6.31,3.22546,-0.982297,2.47928 +6.315,3.22836,-0.938633,2.48655 +6.32,3.22695,-0.862573,2.48877 +6.325,3.22144,-0.756847,2.48568 +6.33,3.2126,-0.625123,2.47771 +6.335,3.20168,-0.47189,2.46594 +6.34,3.19022,-0.302357,2.45194 +6.345,3.17981,-0.122333,2.43757 +6.35,3.1719,0.0619179,2.4248 +6.355,3.16759,0.243861,2.41539 +6.36,3.16748,0.416924,2.41073 +6.365,3.17161,0.574763,2.4115 +6.37,3.1794,0.711547,2.41766 +6.375,3.18979,0.822226,2.42831 +6.38,3.20131,0.902772,2.44191 +6.385,3.21234,0.950356,2.45647 +6.39,3.2213,0.963443,2.46986 +6.395,3.22692,0.94181,2.48021 +6.4,3.22843,0.886482,2.4861 +6.405,3.22562,0.799625,2.48681 +6.41,3.21894,0.684403,2.48233 +6.415,3.20934,0.544852,2.47333 +6.42,3.19819,0.385756,2.46107 +6.425,3.18703,0.212534,2.44722 +6.43,3.17742,0.0311158,2.43369 +6.435,3.17068,-0.152216,2.42236 +6.44,3.16771,-0.331012,2.41485 +6.445,3.16895,-0.498887,2.41228 +6.45,3.17424,-0.649772,2.41511 +6.455,3.18286,-0.778171,2.42299 +6.46,3.19364,-0.879414,2.43482 +6.465,3.20506,-0.949856,2.44891 +6.47,3.21552,-0.98704,2.46322 +6.475,3.22352,-0.989764,2.47569 +6.48,3.22791,-0.958097,2.48457 +6.485,3.22804,-0.893307,2.48866 +6.49,3.22391,-0.797762,2.48743 +6.495,3.2161,-0.67481,2.48108 +6.5,3.20572,-0.528661,2.47049 +6.505,3.19424,-0.364281,2.45706 +6.51,3.18325,-0.18728,2.44258 +6.515,3.1743,-0.00378053,2.42901 +6.52,3.16862,0.179755,2.41823 +6.525,3.167,0.356738,2.41177 +6.53,3.16969,0.520712,2.41059 +6.535,3.17631,0.665631,2.41491 +6.54,3.18595,0.786136,2.42413 +6.545,3.19727,0.877811,2.4369 +6.55,3.20865,0.937383,2.45136 +6.555,3.21849,0.96285,2.46539 +6.56,3.2254,0.953526,2.477 +6.565,3.22839,0.910002,2.48458 +6.57,3.22707,0.834054,2.48715 +6.575,3.22167,0.728506,2.48447 +6.58,3.21297,0.5971,2.47696 +6.585,3.20221,0.444365,2.46569 +6.59,3.1909,0.275509,2.45221 +6.595,3.1806,0.0962948,2.43837 +6.6,3.17273,-0.0871013,2.42606 +6.605,3.16836,-0.268264,2.41704 +6.61,3.1681,-0.440758,2.41263 +6.615,3.17199,-0.598369,2.41352 +6.62,3.17951,-0.735369,2.41968 +6.625,3.18966,-0.846765,2.43026 +6.63,3.20101,-0.928527,2.44375 +6.635,3.21197,-0.977761,2.45821 +6.64,3.22099,-0.992817,2.47155 +6.645,3.22677,-0.973313,2.48188 +6.65,3.22847,-0.920101,2.48778 +6.655,3.22585,-0.835172,2.48848 +6.66,3.21928,-0.721537,2.48391 +6.665,3.20968,-0.583113,2.47471 +6.67,3.19843,-0.424607,2.4621 +6.675,3.18708,-0.251415,2.44778 +6.68,3.17722,-0.0694942,2.43365 +6.685,3.17024,0.114791,2.42166 +6.69,3.16709,0.294869,2.4135 +6.695,3.16823,0.464205,2.41036 +6.7,3.1735,0.616572,2.41273 +6.705,3.1822,0.746338,2.42032 +6.71,3.1931,0.848724,2.43203 +6.715,3.20467,0.920031,2.44613 +6.72,3.21527,0.957796,2.46058 +6.725,3.22338,0.960863,2.47327 +6.73,3.22787,0.929377,2.48245 +6.735,3.2281,0.864705,2.48688 +6.74,3.22409,0.769313,2.48606 +6.745,3.21642,0.646632,2.48016 +6.75,3.20621,0.500924,2.47006 +6.755,3.19488,0.33717,2.45715 +6.76,3.18403,0.160949,2.4432 +6.765,3.17513,-0.0216904,2.43012 +6.77,3.16942,-0.204396,2.41975 +6.775,3.16767,-0.380712,2.41358 +6.78,3.17013,-0.544317,2.41257 +6.785,3.17648,-0.689279,2.41692 +6.79,3.18586,-0.810316,2.42608 +6.795,3.19698,-0.903032,2.43876 +6.8,3.20827,-0.964112,2.45311 +6.805,3.21815,-0.991454,2.46708 +6.81,3.22519,-0.984225,2.47867 +6.815,3.22838,-0.942848,2.48626 +6.82,3.22726,-0.86892,2.48884 +6.825,3.22199,-0.765103,2.4861 +6.83,3.21332,-0.635005,2.47842 +6.835,3.20249,-0.483064,2.46686 +6.84,3.191,-0.314443,2.45294 +6.845,3.18046,-0.134916,2.43853 +6.85,3.17234,0.0492788,2.42558 +6.855,3.16777,0.231617,2.4159 +6.86,3.16738,0.40552,2.41089 +6.865,3.17124,0.56462,2.41129 +6.87,3.17883,0.703039,2.4171 +6.875,3.18909,0.815665,2.4275 +6.88,3.20058,0.898395,2.44096 +6.885,3.21168,0.94831,2.45552 +6.89,3.22082,0.963787,2.46905 +6.895,3.22669,0.944514,2.47965 +6.9,3.22848,0.891434,2.48587 +6.905,3.22596,0.806639,2.48694 +6.91,3.21951,0.69323,2.4828 +6.915,3.21008,0.555188,2.47408 +6.92,3.19899,0.397249,2.46199 +6.925,3.1878,0.224794,2.4482 +6.93,3.17804,0.0437209,2.43459 +6.935,3.17107,-0.139705,2.42305 +6.94,3.16783,-0.319038,2.41524 +6.945,3.16877,-0.48788,2.41231 +6.95,3.17379,-0.640131,2.41476 +6.955,3.18221,-0.770248,2.42231 +6.96,3.19287,-0.873494,2.43392 +6.965,3.2043,-0.946151,2.44791 +6.97,3.21487,-0.985675,2.46227 +6.975,3.22308,-0.990779,2.47493 +6.98,3.22775,-0.961443,2.48411 +6.985,3.2282,-0.898859,2.48856 +6.99,3.22436,-0.805322,2.48771 +6.995,3.21678,-0.684117,2.4817 +7,3.20654,-0.539398,2.47136 +7.005,3.19507,-0.376084,2.45806 +7.01,3.18399,-0.199745,2.44359 +7.015,3.17484,-0.0164725,2.42989 +7.02,3.1689,0.167286,2.41885 +7.025,3.16698,0.344943,2.41205 +7.03,3.16937,0.510023,2.41049 +7.035,3.17574,0.656443,2.41444 +7.04,3.18522,0.778788,2.42336 +7.045,3.19647,0.87257,2.43595 +7.05,3.20792,0.934432,2.45036 +7.055,3.21793,0.962282,2.4645 +7.06,3.22508,0.955344,2.47634 +7.065,3.22837,0.914125,2.48424 +7.07,3.22734,0.840322,2.48717 +7.075,3.22219,0.736691,2.48484 +7.08,3.21367,0.606917,2.47762 +7.085,3.20299,0.455479,2.46656 +7.09,3.19166,0.287542,2.45317 +7.095,3.18124,0.108835,2.43928 +7.1,3.17316,-0.0744879,2.42681 +7.105,3.16853,-0.256022,2.41752 +7.11,3.16798,-0.429324,2.41276 +7.115,3.17161,-0.588158,2.41329 +7.12,3.17892,-0.726753,2.41911 +7.125,3.18893,-0.840057,2.42943 +7.13,3.20026,-0.923968,2.44279 +7.135,3.2113,-0.97551,2.45725 +7.14,3.22049,-0.992943,2.47072 +7.145,3.22651,-0.975802,2.48131 +7.15,3.2285,-0.924854,2.48754 +7.155,3.22616,-0.842016,2.4886 +7.16,3.21983,-0.730235,2.48438 +7.165,3.21041,-0.593367,2.47546 +7.17,3.19922,-0.43607,2.46304 +7.175,3.18783,-0.263695,2.44878 +7.18,3.17784,-0.0821663,2.43458 +7.185,3.17062,0.102174,2.42239 +7.19,3.1672,0.282761,2.41393 +7.195,3.16804,0.453048,2.41042 +7.2,3.17305,0.606778,2.41241 +7.205,3.18153,0.738269,2.41966 +7.21,3.19232,0.842674,2.43112 +7.215,3.20389,0.916216,2.44513 +7.22,3.21459,0.956341,2.45961 +7.225,3.22292,0.961805,2.47249 +7.23,3.22768,0.932665,2.48195 +7.235,3.22823,0.870207,2.48675 +7.24,3.2245,0.776826,2.48629 +7.245,3.21707,0.655891,2.48073 +7.25,3.20699,0.511611,2.47088 +7.255,3.19569,0.348921,2.45811 +7.26,3.18475,0.173362,2.44417 +7.265,3.17568,-0.00904318,2.43097 +7.27,3.1697,-0.191957,2.42035 +7.275,3.16766,-0.368924,2.41385 +7.28,3.16982,-0.533605,2.41246 +7.285,3.17592,-0.680032,2.41645 +7.29,3.18513,-0.802872,2.42531 +7.295,3.19618,-0.897659,2.4378 +7.3,3.20752,-0.961,2.45211 +7.305,3.21755,-0.990705,2.46618 +7.31,3.22484,-0.985857,2.478 +7.315,3.22832,-0.946791,2.48591 +7.32,3.2275,-0.875027,2.48885 +7.325,3.2225,-0.773159,2.48647 +7.33,3.21402,-0.644733,2.4791 +7.335,3.20328,-0.494134,2.46776 +7.34,3.19177,-0.326478,2.45394 +7.345,3.18111,-0.147501,2.43949 +7.35,3.17278,0.0365836,2.42638 +7.355,3.16794,0.219265,2.41642 +7.36,3.16726,0.393961,2.41105 +7.365,3.17084,0.554279,2.41108 +7.37,3.17821,0.694298,2.41655 +7.375,3.18834,0.808848,2.42667 +7.38,3.19981,0.893745,2.43999 +7.385,3.21099,0.945988,2.45454 +7.39,3.22031,0.963861,2.46821 +7.395,3.22643,0.946963,2.47905 +7.4,3.2285,0.896155,2.48561 +7.405,3.22626,0.813452,2.48704 +7.41,3.22005,0.701892,2.48324 +7.415,3.21078,0.565399,2.4748 +7.42,3.19976,0.408662,2.46289 +7.425,3.18853,0.23702,2.44916 +7.43,3.17864,0.0563389,2.43548 +7.435,3.17145,-0.127134,2.42375 +7.44,3.16794,-0.306959,2.41564 +7.445,3.16859,-0.476727,2.41235 +7.45,3.17335,-0.630309,2.41443 +7.455,3.18156,-0.762114,2.42166 +7.46,3.1921,-0.867344,2.43303 +7.465,3.20352,-0.942204,2.44691 +7.47,3.2142,-0.984065,2.46131 +7.475,3.22261,-0.991553,2.47415 +7.48,3.22755,-0.964564,2.48361 +7.485,3.2283,-0.904206,2.48841 +7.49,3.22475,-0.812705,2.48793 +7.495,3.21741,-0.693279,2.48227 +7.5,3.20731,-0.550029,2.47219 +7.505,3.19589,-0.387821,2.45905 +7.51,3.18473,-0.212186,2.44459 +7.515,3.1754,-0.0291845,2.43078 +7.52,3.1692,0.154754,2.4195 +7.525,3.16698,0.333044,2.41236 +7.53,3.16906,0.499194,2.41042 +7.535,3.17518,0.647083,2.41399 +7.54,3.18448,0.771243,2.4226 +7.545,3.19566,0.867114,2.43499 +7.55,3.20715,0.931256,2.44935 +7.555,3.21731,0.961489,2.46358 +7.56,3.22471,0.956945,2.47564 +7.565,3.22829,0.918045,2.48385 +7.57,3.22757,0.846408,2.48715 +7.575,3.22269,0.744722,2.48518 +7.58,3.21436,0.616611,2.47827 +7.585,3.20378,0.466505,2.46743 +7.59,3.19243,0.299525,2.45414 +7.595,3.18189,0.121364,2.44021 +7.6,3.17361,-0.0618467,2.42758 +7.605,3.16871,-0.243713,2.41801 +7.61,3.16787,-0.417787,2.41292 +7.615,3.17122,-0.577811,2.41308 +7.62,3.17832,-0.717972,2.41855 +7.625,3.18819,-0.833163,2.42861 +7.63,3.19948,-0.919208,2.44182 +7.635,3.2106,-0.97305,2.45627 +7.64,3.21996,-0.992862,2.46988 +7.645,3.22624,-0.978091,2.48072 +7.65,3.22851,-0.929421,2.48728 +7.655,3.22646,-0.848696,2.4887 +7.66,3.22037,-0.738792,2.48483 +7.665,3.21112,-0.60351,2.4762 +7.67,3.2,-0.447455,2.46397 +7.675,3.18858,-0.275933,2.44978 +7.68,3.17844,-0.0948341,2.43551 +7.685,3.17101,0.089523,2.42313 +7.69,3.16731,0.270581,2.41437 +7.695,3.16786,0.441784,2.41049 +7.7,3.1726,0.596847,2.41211 +7.705,3.18088,0.730036,2.41902 +7.71,3.19155,0.836442,2.43024 +7.715,3.2031,0.912207,2.44413 +7.72,3.21392,0.954689,2.45864 +7.725,3.22244,0.962552,2.47169 +7.73,3.22748,0.935767,2.48143 +7.735,3.22832,0.875538,2.48657 +7.74,3.22488,0.784189,2.48648 +7.745,3.21767,0.665025,2.48126 +7.75,3.20774,0.522202,2.47167 +7.755,3.19649,0.360608,2.45906 +7.76,3.18548,0.185746,2.44514 +7.765,3.17623,0.0036108,2.43182 +7.77,3.17001,-0.179476,2.42097 +7.775,3.16767,-0.35706,2.41415 +7.78,3.16954,-0.522785,2.41238 +7.785,3.17539,-0.67065,2.41601 +7.79,3.18441,-0.795269,2.42456 +7.795,3.19538,-0.89211,2.43685 +7.8,3.20675,-0.957702,2.4511 +7.805,3.21693,-0.989768,2.46526 +7.81,3.22444,-0.987303,2.47729 +7.815,3.22822,-0.950558,2.48552 +7.82,3.2277,-0.880975,2.48883 +7.825,3.22298,-0.781077,2.48681 +7.83,3.21471,-0.654348,2.47976 +7.835,3.20408,-0.505119,2.46864 +7.84,3.19256,-0.338459,2.45493 +7.845,3.18179,-0.160066,2.44046 +7.85,3.17325,0.0238739,2.42719 +7.855,3.16813,0.206865,2.41697 +7.86,3.16715,0.382319,2.41125 +7.865,3.17046,0.543825,2.4109 +7.87,3.17759,0.685419,2.416 +7.875,3.18758,0.80187,2.42585 +7.88,3.19901,0.888921,2.43901 +7.885,3.21027,0.943483,2.45355 +7.89,3.21977,0.963751,2.46734 +7.895,3.22614,0.949234,2.47844 +7.9,3.22851,0.90071,2.48532 +7.905,3.22656,0.820117,2.48711 +7.91,3.22059,0.710428,2.48366 +7.915,3.21149,0.57551,2.4755 +7.92,3.20053,0.420002,2.46379 +7.925,3.18927,0.249203,2.45012 +7.93,3.17924,0.0689472,2.43638 +7.935,3.17183,-0.114539,2.42446 +7.94,3.16805,-0.294823,2.41605 +7.945,3.16842,-0.465486,2.41241 +7.95,3.17291,-0.62037,2.41412 +7.955,3.18091,-0.75384,2.42102 +7.96,3.19134,-0.861035,2.43215 +7.965,3.20275,-0.938085,2.44592 +7.97,3.21352,-0.982278,2.46035 +7.975,3.22213,-0.992152,2.47335 +7.98,3.22733,-0.967515,2.48309 +7.985,3.22837,-0.909396,2.48824 +7.99,3.22511,-0.819947,2.48813 +7.995,3.218,-0.702323,2.48281 +8,3.20806,-0.560565,2.473 diff --git a/img/data/cylinder2d_two_level_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv b/img/data/cylinder2d_two_level_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e2133a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/img/data/cylinder2d_two_level_refinement_n40_re100_drag_lift_deltap.csv @@ -0,0 +1,1602 @@ +time,drag,lift,deltap +0,0,0,0 +0.0025,2.03702e-06,-6.19089e-09,1.25649e-06 +0.005,1.2815e-05,-2.67632e-08,7.75131e-06 +0.0075,3.30771e-05,-6.09379e-08,1.97631e-05 +0.01,6.32438e-05,-1.09298e-07,3.74259e-05 +0.0125,0.000103645,-1.70914e-07,6.08375e-05 +0.015,0.000154562,-2.48605e-07,9.00802e-05 +0.0175,0.000218987,-3.39734e-07,0.000126896 +0.02,0.000296724,-4.45235e-07,0.000170987 +0.0225,0.000385717,-5.6122e-07,0.000221058 +0.025,0.000486324,-6.90209e-07,0.000277277 +0.0275,0.000598658,-8.33302e-07,0.000339659 +0.03,0.000722818,-9.88811e-07,0.000408214 +0.0325,0.000857972,-1.15489e-06,0.000482378 +0.035,0.00100125,-1.33269e-06,0.000560422 +0.0375,0.00115684,-1.52333e-06,0.000644872 +0.04,0.00132441,-1.72813e-06,0.000735462 +0.0425,0.00150421,-1.94483e-06,0.000832284 +0.045,0.00169637,-2.17352e-06,0.000935368 +0.0475,0.00190141,-2.41287e-06,0.00104498 +0.05,0.00212223,-2.66643e-06,0.00116283 +0.0525,0.00235698,-2.92969e-06,0.00128767 +0.055,0.00260455,-3.20381e-06,0.00141882 +0.0575,0.00286519,-3.4875e-06,0.00155639 +0.06,0.0031389,-3.78027e-06,0.00170036 +0.0625,0.00342553,-4.08395e-06,0.00185061 +0.065,0.00372359,-4.39638e-06,0.0020062 +0.0675,0.00403169,-4.71819e-06,0.00216633 +0.07,0.00435347,-5.0502e-06,0.00233319 +0.0725,0.00468815,-5.39083e-06,0.00250624 +0.075,0.005036,-5.74222e-06,0.00268563 +0.0775,0.00539715,-6.1024e-06,0.00287139 +0.08,0.00577254,-6.47081e-06,0.00306407 +0.0825,0.0061645,-6.84796e-06,0.00326501 +0.085,0.00657025,-7.23312e-06,0.00347243 +0.0875,0.00698962,-7.62471e-06,0.00368626 +0.09,0.00742267,-8.02354e-06,0.00390649 +0.0925,0.00786933,-8.42888e-06,0.00413308 +0.095,0.00832914,-8.83961e-06,0.00436571 +0.0975,0.0088004,-9.25582e-06,0.00460335 +0.1,0.00928308,-9.67852e-06,0.00484604 +0.1025,0.00977995,-1.01082e-05,0.00509541 +0.105,0.0102901,-1.0544e-05,0.00535085 +0.1075,0.0108137,-1.09842e-05,0.00561255 +0.11,0.0113512,-1.14298e-05,0.00588061 +0.1125,0.0119037,-1.18809e-05,0.00615578 +0.115,0.0124728,-1.23367e-05,0.00643887 +0.1175,0.0130552,-1.27955e-05,0.00672794 +0.12,0.0136517,-1.32568e-05,0.00702339 +0.1225,0.014262,-1.37208e-05,0.00732505 +0.125,0.0148859,-1.41872e-05,0.00763285 +0.1275,0.0155228,-1.46559e-05,0.00794631 +0.13,0.016171,-1.51252e-05,0.00826448 +0.1325,0.0168316,-1.55965e-05,0.00858807 +0.135,0.0175063,-1.60695e-05,0.00891806 +0.1375,0.0181943,-1.65434e-05,0.00925393 +0.14,0.018896,-1.70188e-05,0.00959588 +0.1425,0.0196116,-1.74942e-05,0.00994415 +0.145,0.0203427,-1.79691e-05,0.0102995 +0.1475,0.0210897,-1.84434e-05,0.0106622 +0.15,0.0218497,-1.89156e-05,0.0110305 +0.1525,0.0226238,-1.93853e-05,0.011405 +0.155,0.0234114,-1.98517e-05,0.0117855 +0.1575,0.0242125,-2.03146e-05,0.0121718 +0.16,0.025026,-2.07735e-05,0.0125632 +0.1625,0.0258506,-2.12282e-05,0.0129592 +0.165,0.0266883,-2.16783e-05,0.0133608 +0.1675,0.0275397,-2.21233e-05,0.0137684 +0.17,0.0284041,-2.25629e-05,0.0141817 +0.1725,0.0292821,-2.29963e-05,0.0146008 +0.175,0.0301742,-2.34232e-05,0.0150262 +0.1775,0.0310816,-2.38427e-05,0.0154586 +0.18,0.032004,-2.42532e-05,0.0158976 +0.1825,0.032939,-2.46536e-05,0.0163418 +0.185,0.0338879,-2.50432e-05,0.0167921 +0.1875,0.0348499,-2.54216e-05,0.017248 +0.19,0.0358249,-2.57883e-05,0.0177094 +0.1925,0.0368116,-2.61414e-05,0.0181755 +0.195,0.0378095,-2.64805e-05,0.018646 +0.1975,0.0388206,-2.68062e-05,0.0191222 +0.2,0.0398447,-2.7117e-05,0.019604 +0.2025,0.0408817,-2.74116e-05,0.0200913 +0.205,0.041932,-2.76893e-05,0.0205843 +0.2075,0.0429963,-2.79488e-05,0.0210834 +0.21,0.0440755,-2.81894e-05,0.0215893 +0.2125,0.0451687,-2.8409e-05,0.0221012 +0.215,0.0462742,-2.8606e-05,0.0226181 +0.2175,0.0473932,-2.87796e-05,0.0231409 +0.22,0.0485249,-2.8928e-05,0.0236691 +0.2225,0.0496689,-2.90503e-05,0.0242022 +0.225,0.0508239,-2.91452e-05,0.0247399 +0.2275,0.0519903,-2.92115e-05,0.025282 +0.23,0.0531697,-2.92483e-05,0.0258299 +0.2325,0.0543616,-2.92537e-05,0.026383 +0.235,0.0555661,-2.92263e-05,0.0269415 +0.2375,0.0567837,-2.91648e-05,0.0275057 +0.24,0.0580152,-2.90669e-05,0.028076 +0.2425,0.059261,-2.89305e-05,0.0286528 +0.245,0.0605199,-2.87535e-05,0.0292351 +0.2475,0.061791,-2.85342e-05,0.0298226 +0.25,0.0630752,-2.82702e-05,0.0304158 +0.2525,0.0643716,-2.79595e-05,0.0310142 +0.255,0.0656798,-2.76001e-05,0.0316175 +0.2575,0.0669987,-2.71895e-05,0.0322252 +0.26,0.0683291,-2.67265e-05,0.0328377 +0.2625,0.0696724,-2.62089e-05,0.033456 +0.265,0.0710278,-2.56341e-05,0.0340794 +0.2675,0.0723958,-2.49994e-05,0.0347085 +0.27,0.0737769,-2.43024e-05,0.0353434 +0.2725,0.0751718,-2.35404e-05,0.0359847 +0.275,0.0765807,-2.27103e-05,0.0366324 +0.2775,0.0780021,-2.18084e-05,0.0372856 +0.28,0.0794359,-2.0832e-05,0.0379444 +0.2825,0.0808826,-1.97785e-05,0.0386089 +0.285,0.0823414,-1.86443e-05,0.0392789 +0.2875,0.0838116,-1.74263e-05,0.0399539 +0.29,0.0852928,-1.61214e-05,0.0406338 +0.2925,0.0867861,-1.47265e-05,0.0413192 +0.295,0.0882925,-1.32388e-05,0.0420107 +0.2975,0.0898109,-1.1654e-05,0.0427079 +0.3,0.0913425,-9.96871e-06,0.0434113 +0.3025,0.0928875,-8.17932e-06,0.0441212 +0.305,0.0944469,-6.28162e-06,0.0448381 +0.3075,0.0960202,-4.27106e-06,0.0455619 +0.31,0.0976062,-2.14338e-06,0.0462918 +0.3125,0.0992054,1.0523e-07,0.0470281 +0.315,0.100818,2.47941e-06,0.0477709 +0.3175,0.102443,4.98356e-06,0.0485199 +0.32,0.10408,7.62188e-06,0.0492748 +0.3225,0.105729,1.03984e-05,0.0500357 +0.325,0.107391,1.33173e-05,0.0508034 +0.3275,0.109067,1.63838e-05,0.